Reviews for Rosario's Pizzeria in Seaford, NY
Pizza is delicious. Eggplant absolutely fantastic. The owner, complete gentleman. Stand up guy. Service is spot on. Been going... there since opened. Must try. Read more
Delicious pizza and specialty slices!! Perfect spot to stop for a quick slice when you're on the go. 5 stars for Rosarios!!
Our first time here. The staff and owner are very nice people. We had the upsidown slice and the garlic knots and they were very... good. The knots were nice and soft which is something I haven't seen in other pizzerias and I loved them. We will be back! Read more
Ok the only thing bad here is they're not giving it away for free and I don't live next door.. I drive from West Sayville and... Freeport to eat there. Prices are great, food over the top great! The review saying his two slices were bad when he took ithome and reheated it probably left it in the trunk for a month. Everything is fresh place is busy. Owner is super proud of hisfood and talents. There's nothing there not fresh place is hopping. Best pizza place ever. Great pasta dinners there too. Bestcrust in the world, not oily from cheap cheese, sauce is deadly great. Many types of slices creating new all the time. Entirebook of probably 100 previous creations. Not the owners business it's his love. Great service and staff. Great decor andspotless restaurant and restroom. Read more
I had my pizza delivered. I ordered 3 different types. All were good. What I was happiest with, was the amount of toppings. I... got a regular pie, with 3 topping. There was so much, one slice was a meal. I will be going there again! Read more
Love this pizza. I've eaten this slice a few times and for someone who comes from Brooklyn this pizza is authentic. When you... fold it to take your first bite the pizza doesn't sag, it stays firm and crisp. Sauce isn't sweet tasting like jarred sauce,tastes like fresh tomatoes. I recently learned that the owner closed up shop in Brooklyn after 30 years or so and packed up hisoriginal ovens and set them up here on long Island. That's pretty impressive. Read more
Pizza snob here; I love the crust at this pizza place-it is crisp and thin, and the cheese is flavorful. The plain pizza is the... best I've ever had, and the eggplant is a personal favorite. Pizzas are large and reasonably priced. The only pizza worth eatingin the area; my family says it is as good as New Park was in the 80s. You can also get pizza by the slice here, which they heatwhile you wait. Highly recommended. Read more
8 bucks for one slice and a fountain drink, not great