Reviews for T J's New York Style Pizzeria in Sebastian, FL

Best NY style pizza I've had south of Virginia

Not typical. But if you know you know. Good food. Worth paying the cash for. If you have a complaint its probably your own fault... most likely. Read more

The Italian sub I got was just average. Haven't tried the pizza yet, new to the area. There is a disadvantage to being a cash... only establishment. Read more

It's pretty good Pizza, just make sure you have cash it's almost always cash only.

I was a HUGE fan of this place until tonight, I called an order in as usual and as usual I said delivery but the guy on the... phone must have put it in as pickup. Long story short an hour goes by and they call me saying my order is ready to be picked upwith some lunatic throwing a fit cursing and screaming that I told him pickup not delivery. YOUR WRONG DILD! Read more

Usually very good. Good service. My only issue is there's barely any sauce on the pizzas. I think I'll have to order extra next... time to get it right. Read more

Good pizza. I love that its cash only. I see a lot of people complain about it but thats how it should be, cash only. Kick rocks... if you don't like it Read more

Sebastian is a small town so Pizza selection is limited. With that said, this place holds its own with pizza. If you're a fan... of the thinner, crunchier crust this place is for you. Not overly impressed with their wings. They were REALLY little And manyof them broken. I'm pretty sure they counted each half of the broken ones as ONE. Hot wings definitely aren't HOT. Last butnot least- this is a CASH ONLY establishment. Honestly, this is a real issue in this day and age. Who carries cash? Anyonecan download Venmo and accept payments. If all you carry is a card then this place isn't an option for you. Read more