Reviews for Pago's Pizzeria and Italian Cuisine in Sedona, AZ

Food, service and atmosphere this place has it all. My wife and I loved the Italian music in the background. The Alfredo... Shrimp tasted so good and the shrimp were huge!!! The spaghetti and meatballs were excellent. The minestrone soup was so goodit reminded me of my Italian Aunts cooking, all of it. You gotta try this place, it's much more than a pizzeria, it's fineItalian food. We could not finish due to they gave us too much so we took it home in a box. Read more

As with some of my reviews, this one is WAY overdue and for that I am so very sorry to the fine crew at Pago's in Sedona. Why? ... Because we had some of the best dang pizza EVAH in February of this year while we were in the area for a quick vacation. If youfollow me, you know 2 things. First of all, I try to pick out something about the dish I am rating that sets it aside fromsimilar dishes at other restaurants. And at Pago's, it's easy. The meats! Now, I'm not saying if you prefer your very owncheese pizza like Kevin in Home Alone, you won't get a fine pizza, but Pago's goes over the top with their meats. Just check outthis pic of the meaty pie we ordered off the "Create Your Own" menu. We chose sausage, pepperoni. bacon, and meatballs. Anyway, you can plainly see that it was loaded. So ... 5 stars for the pie. 5 stars for the service (waitress was veryfriendly) 5 stars for the cleanliness (read below) Now, the restrooms. You know we travel lots, and you know I check out therestrooms. At 2pm this Saturday afternoon, I can say that I was pleased to find that it was pretty tidy, save for a few dropsof water on the counter. Good job Pago's, stuff like this is important to travelers! Read more

Great food, I couldn't eat while there and ordered something to go. I my spaghetti cold 4 hours later and it was delicious, ... heated it up and enjoyed my meal. My son had the small Chicago style pizza and my niece had the spaghetti, I ordered based onher recommendation. We got to the restaurant around 4 and there weren't many people. The kids kept commenting why the place wasempty if it was so delicious, when we were leaving some time after 5, people were pouring in. My kids love food, from the ageof 1 they didn't like junk food, they ate sushi, salmon, steak, vegetables and any other adult healthy meal. They love foodfoods, I trust their pallet. Do for great Italian food at a great price, this is your stop! They also said cheesecake wasgreat and the cannoli was amazing! Read more

I will say I was highly disappointed in this restaurant. We got there and were sat quickly. Our server passed us up a few times... before coming to speak to us. It wasn't busy at all. There were 4 families at the time we were there. The only plus thing I haveto say about this restaurant is the calamari was delicious and on par. That is where the 2 stars came from. The pizza my sonordered was greasy and hard. I knew it was bad when my son who eats pizza chose no to eat it. I ordered the chicken parm mealwhich says comes with pasta. The pasta was penne and that was hard to adjust to. The sauce wasn't sticking to the noodles. Thenthe chicken was under cooked slightly. I ended up eating 3 bites out of it and left it there. Dessert was lemon cake and it washyped up as being fresh and one of the best desserts they have. That was a lie. It was a frozen cake and it tasted frost burn. Read more

I have lots of allergies and they were able to make my special order. The shrimp are very good quality much better than many... other restaurants. I especially appreciated that they devein the shrimp properly. The others I was with ate pizza which theydefinitely enjoyed. We had a large group and they were able to keep us all well taken care of. Read more

I was concerned dining here after reading the reviews. Ended up having a good experience. Pretty good Italian food. Our... waitress, Jasmine was friendly and attentive. I had the Hawaiian calzone, asked for it to be cooked a little longer for a moregolden brown top on the dough since the pics on the other reviews did appear to be very pale. The kitchen delivered. We alsoordered the chicken parm, the chicken was a bit thicker than I like the flavor made up for it though. The side of chips was odd.Definitely not expecting that as a side with an Italian dish but they were so good. Homemade potato chips. They were very good! Read more

Friendly staff and very fast service. The calamari was over fried I had to peel the crust, the shrimp scampi was not bad but... lacking flavor. Probably because it was near closing time. The lemon peper chicken was great! I would still recommend the place! Read more

We tried this place for dinner while visiting some friends. We were greeted and seated quickly. Our server Trevor was very... friendly and attentive. I ordered the Veal Scaloppini and my partner ordered the Meat Ravioli. Both were very delicious the Vealwas cooked to perfection. The Pasta was so delicious. Also ordered Meatballs and Italian Sausage for appetizer. The Meatballswere homemade and so good. The Italian Sausage had great flavor and was just fantastic. We ordered the Lemon Cake for dessertand unbelievable how good it tasted that our companions ordered one also. The restaurant was clean as were the restrooms. Cannotwait to return on our next visit. Read more