Reviews for Strathmore Bagels in Selden, NY
They have great bagels. I go there a lot to get chicken salad on an egg bagel. Very delicious. The staff is awesome!
Now that's a sandwich!!! Great friendly staff, and loved the Italian stallion, comes with a side of coleslaw and a pickle,... delicious! Read more
GLUTEN FREE FRIENDLY** They have a separate toaster for people with an allergy. The staff is very knowledgeable regarding... cross-contamination. Highly recommend if you need a gluten-free bagel on the go. Read more
If the older blonde woman was more friendly and listened to the entire order before grabbing bagels and starting to cut, she... wouldn't have to drop her shoulders in annoyance at the customer she's too rude to turn around and look at. 11+$ for 4bagels...attitude, free. Read more
Don't go here early morning unless you want attitude and a messed up order. Especially from the chubby lady. She has plenty of... attitude to give out. I asked for an egg and cheese sandwich on a bagel and I got egg and cheese sandwich on a bagel with hashbrowns and bacon. I don't eat pork and I never remember asking for hash browns. Thanks for making my bagel completely inediblefrom the bacon. My mom asked for an untoasted plain bagel with veg cream cheese and they gave her a burnt bagel. The worst partis they have a sign in front of register which verbatim says 4% discount for cash paying customers. When I asked about it shesaid I've literally never heard of that. Um... Don't you even know what the signs in your own store say? Grossly disrespectfulbehavior. Go elsewhere. Read more
Ordered from Uber eats and this is how they treat my food at Strathmote bagels, when I called to complain they kept me on hold... for 5 mins and didn?t return to the line. Worse place I?ve ever gotten an eggg sandwich from ! Read more
Lighty toasted, with butter should not look burnt with a gallon of butter leaking thru the wrap, soaking the brown bag and... staining the seat of my car. 2nd day in a row I went to this bagel shop and recieved a burnt un edible bagel. Used to come hereon a daily when I lived here but the quality just went down I assume. This is ridiculous. Read more
Horrible Service at Selden location. Ordered an Omelette that was filled with egg shells. Called spoke to manager and she told... me she made the omelette and no shell was in it. I offered to bring the omelette back so that she can see, of course she saidno. The price was not worth what I received and the girls have attitudes. I will not purchase from there ever again. Not worthit Read more