Reviews for The Neighbors Sports Grille & Wings in Selden, NY

Kailee was outstanding throughout my whole experience. I was having a rough day and Kailee went above and beyond to cater to all... of my needs, due to my experience i will definitely the back and ask for Kailee specifically. Read more

This place takes me by surprise a bit. You wouldn't expect a small little sports bar in Selden to be considered really good, but... the food was really really good. I came with a group and we got a wrap, a beyond burger, a cheddar jalapeno burger and a texasstyled burger. The burgers were extremely flavorful. I took my first bite and was in shock because I wasnt expecting a punch offlavors and seasonings. The fries were just the right crisp served in cute little frying baskets. The other guests meals, theytold me, were great. I can't wait to come here next and have some good chicken. The servers, owners, etc were all extremely niceand helpful and they seemed very happy. I only have 2 very minimal critiques. One is that the sodas tasted kinda like knock-offaof coca cola or pepsi products, but like werent bad where i cared too much. Two, atmosphere needs a little work, mainly becauseit kinda smelled like bleach when I was in there. Read more

My Sister works there ..We enjoyed the food .

This is what they call Sheppard's Pie. It was gross, and I sent it back after 3 bites. Owner would NOT take it off the bill!!!... He said He would only take 50% off the meal. Never AGAIN!!!!!!!!!! Read more

First time ordering from this place. If you like a good chicken wings this is not the place for you. I ordered 20 pieces of... chicken wings in two different flavors. The wings were soggy and not well fried. The sauce was just thrown on as an afterthought. The french fries soaked in grease. Definitely will not recommend. Horrible dinner for $35. Read more

Jenn was an awesome bartender who checked on me consistently. The ppl were friendly. I had the bacon meal. It was the first time... I had bacon like this. It was delicious. The cook came out and shook my hand. I was a happy camper. ???? You will need to eatit with a fork and knife. Do not try to eat it with your hands like a peasant. ???????????? Read more

I've been in the food industry for 18 years. Last night spent 35 dollars plus a 5 dollar tip for this trash. I wanted to support... a local business and you guys ensured that I will never be back. I have never written a review on any establishment ever; butthis was the most disappointing experience I've ever had. Gave me 20 boneless "wings" which were just tendons and pieces ofchicken that normal people would throw away. Didn't give me celery or blue cheese. Either the "cook" doesn't know what he wasdoing or the owner is trying to turn profit on the garbage part of the chicken. Would give 0 stars if I could. Read more

Everything was amazing, the food, the server, just everything :) the wings are meaty and absolutely awesome. We got here at... 12:40ish and there were only a few people here, but because there is a bar I feel like it definitely gets busier later in theday :) either way, everything was awesome ???????? Read more