Reviews for Amato's in Selinsgrove, PA
My Nana loves it here. She's totally a local and is greeted by name when she walks in. She took us to lunch and everything was... delicious. We had lasagna, calzone, salad and chicken fingers. Read more
Love this place. We stop almost every Friday on our way to our camper. The owner and staff are incredible. Been going for years.... We just talked our camping friends to go and now their hooked. Read more
Wow! Great specialty pizza....attentive service....nice clean restrooms and VERY worth the price....we will be back!
Slow service, decent food. Alfredo is runny and pretty bland. Good stromboli. Probably not a place we'll go to again very soon.
The medium calzone was big. Enough for 2-3 people easily. It was hot and delicious. Great job over there.
This place is not recommended. There quality of food is ok but they do not know how to cook. They have a good location and... that?s why there still open. I Stromboli and a pizza there and it was undercooked. I gave them plenty of time to make it and itwas so white. They were not even busy at the time. I ordered 2 different times from there and the same thing happened. Wouldn?trecommend it?s a last resort Read more
Good friendly staff of people I love going there when I can I can't complain there foods are exceptional just like there... homemade bread with the pasta/Italian dishes I definitely would Highly recommend tis place only on Tuesdays to Saturdays. Read more
Pizza sauce was good but a bit on the pricy side.