Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Selinsgrove, PA
They have the best pizzas and customer service! I would highly recommend.
I love Papa John's pizza. The staff were very polite. Thanks guys for dealing with our big crowd.
We order online and pick up. We've never had a single problem with the order and it's always been prepared exactly when... requested. No other pizza place in the area is this convenient. Read more
I'll admit, I was skeptical. I've had Papa John's from other locations in the past, abd was not impressed. It was greasy, overly... spicy, and skimped on the cheese - in short, it was ill-balanced and mostly inedible. Tonight, I was pleasantly surprised. Ourpies were ready under the estimated time. The toppings (half sausage & pepperoni; half sausage green & peppers) were plentifuland the pepperoni was crisp and slightly spicy! The cheese was abundant, and the sauce was a nice balance of sweet and acidic.Even the crust had flavor....and they weren't lying when they said "stuffed crust" - 2 slices and I was tapping out. Finally,the customer service was certainly different. The counter person (I'm assuming she was the manager) was helpful, courteous, andeven opened the door for me when I was leaving. I'm usually not a big fan of "chain pizza", but I was completely taken bysurprise with this location. I 100% recommend this location. Read more
Fresh made pizza means papa johns pizza. Thanks Bob taking my order with smile and thanks to the other friend who served me on... my table. It was a great experience here. Ample parking, nice seating inside. Staff is very kind. MGK loves you guys. Keepspreading the pizzazz ?That Works? Read more
The customer service here is great! I've been here numerous times and the service is great no matter who's working. So they've... got a consistent team, which I like. It's not like you go here and see who's working and your like here we go wonder how thisperson is going to be or how my food's going to be. Not here that I've encountered at least. Consistently great service andfood. Also open late and has your order promptly. Keep up the good work! Read more
A large pizza was a bit smaller (14") than expected but great for two people, great deal for their $8 carryout w/ 1 topping.... Plus free garlic dipping sauce :) Update: if you "Papa size" it for $2 it's 16" and with the $8 carryout deal, definitely worthit! I was going to take a picture before we started but we were too excited to eat ???? Read more
Thought we would try something new so we tried it . I didn't think it was bad . We will see how it is again in future . Can't... really judge by one visit. Read more