Reviews for Mazerella's Upper Crust Pizza in Sellersburg, IN

All American local pizza ???? restaurant. Has tasty food, friendly service, super clean, great prices. Kind of place that feels... familiar and comfortable, like you've been going there for years, even if it's your first time. Read more

We found Mazerella?s because of the great online reviews. And they did not disappoint. Craig and his team were timely and the... pizza was tasty and fresh. Mmmmm. Mmmm. I wish we lived close by so we could eat here often. Read more

We decided to try this place while camping in the area. We chose this restaurant based on reviews. It?s obvious that the... employees are empowered to take care of the customers. Our food came out later than expected but we were not bothered. Theemployees obviously realized it was later than it should have been and they went above and beyond to make sure our food andexperience were both great. We wanted to share kudos because that doesn?t really happen anywhere anymore. Great job! I?m surewill be back when we return to the area! Read more

We just moved back to the area and I really enjoyed this pizza! It reminded me of the Mozzarella?s in New Albany, I used to go... to in high school. It was nice having this again 15+ years later. I love the breadsticks and nacho cheese. It?s a rarity to goanywhere these days with two adults and a toddler and it cost us like $25. Such a great value! Read more

We stopped in to try this place when we were in town. Upon entering, we were met by a kind employee that helped us make our... decisions on what to eat. Pizza was really good. There is a pizza buffet, and most of the patrons were dining from the buffet.There is also a small, basic salad bar available. We ordered a pizza, breadsticks, and a dessert pizza. Space is limited. Wesqueezed four people around a table, but didn?t have a lot of room for eating. A couple of patrons were just holding a plate ontheir laps and eating. If we venture back through this community, we will likely dine here again! Read more

Mazerella's is a nice little place just off the highway. Cool staff, clean restaurant, fair price, and a pretty decent pie.... Would recommend if you live in the area or need something besides fast food on your trip. Clean bathrooms as well. Read more

This was my first time here. I've tried many different pizza places across the country and this one by far is the best. I... ordered a Meatza Calzone and an order of Maz Best Breadsticks thinking they wouldn't be that filling so I would have both. TheCalzone was big enough for 2 people to eat, the Breadsticks were huge too there were 6 of them. Everything tasted fantastic! This is my new go to place for a Calzone when I'm in the area. 5 stars all the way!! Read more

Great food first time there and its up there with the best pizza I have had. Thin crust is the best here. Stays crunchy even... with a ton of toppings. We had the Big Z pizza. Highly recommended. Will be back!! Read more