Reviews for DeFelice Bros® Pizza - Shadyside in Shadyside, OH

Ordered two salads. One with extra chicken, one with extra pepperoni. They both had less chicken/pepperoni than a regular order.

Ordered pizza last night at 9 pm didn't get my food until 10:30 then bit into my piece of pizza and bit into metal!! My children... ate this pizza luckily they didn't bite into this. I'm not very happy. I'll b calling at 11 am Read more

I ordered at 7:40pm. Delivery arrived at 9:20pm. I immediately called back upon realizing they forgot the drinks. The driver who... answered the phone said he was leaving on a delivery and was going to drop off my drinks. It?s now 11:15pm. I don?t think mydrinks are coming. Not impressed. Read more

Great pizza, hoagies, even pasta and customer service is solid even when they're busy

I think Defelice has the best pizza around. Love the crust. Perfect pie

Ordered a medium thin crust pepperoni with half jalapeños and got this train wreck. I got a small pizza that wasn?t even cut!... Didn?t even try to get the toppings on half decent. I would be embarrassed to serve this. At least act like you like your job orcare. Shame! Read more

Chicken Parmesan sub was delicious, great bread sauce and just right amount of chicken and cheese. My coworker had antipasto... salad and loved it. Staff was great and made sure experience was enjoyable. Highly recommend! Read more

We had a younger delivery driver who brought us the wrong food by mistake and went to go all the way back to the store to get... the correct order. When he got to his car he realized his mistake and called me back right away to apologize for what hadhappened. Most drivers would've just left and never thought anything of it. He did an amazing job and I didn't get his name butthank you soo much. Helluva guy. Read more