Reviews for Casey's in Sheffield, IA
Pizza was good and prompt service.
Very disappointed... Ordered a pizza tonight and my taco pizza had hardly any toppings. No tomato or cheddar cheese on it like... it's supposed too. I called and they told me I will have to wait till a manager is in the store to fix the issue. I used to workfor a Casey's and I definitely won't be ordering pizza here anymore.. Read more
I love there ice cream
They didn't have the pizzas available I wanted,so I get this call and of course I had to change my pizza to something less than... expected,think I got a discount or anything else for their inconvenience,and worst part they cldnt even cut it all the way thru! Read more
I have ordered pizza from Sheffield 3 times. Only one time did I actually get the pizza I ordered. This time I was in the store... and ordered the pizza for after the school football game. We went to pick it up and they had given it to someone else.! I hopeyou enjoyed it. Next time double check your pizza's people! Read more
Watched employee steal stack of pizza coupons and gave them to a customer. (Toni peterson). Sends security footage to others to... pardons breaking nco Read more
Typically very good pizza however tonight out flat bread pizza is burnt to a crisp
Quick in and out