Reviews for Casey's in Shelburn, IN
Typical gas station with gas station pizza. Nothing special.
I love the fact that my favorite gas station is in my hometown.
Staff was friendly and courteous and helpful the cook let me pay for my order before it was finished cooking. Ordered a meat... lovers pizza with pepperoni, hot sausage and bacon and light sauce. All the was on there was some pepperoni and sausage andit wasn't hot it had a lot of sauce and there was so much grease that your could have put it in a deep fryer and cooked frenchfries in it. Read more
Store is clean, bathroom is clean, friendly staff. I just wish they would write on the single slice pizza what kind it is... instead of my trying to guess. From owner Casey's at 604 E Curry Ave has the best pizza featuring made-from-scratch dough, 100%mozzarella cheese, and only the freshest pizza toppings. We've also got appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, and a variety ofessential groceries. When you're stopping by, you can even fill up your gas tank with quality fuel - Whatever you need, Casey'sis here to help. Read more
The crew at the Casey's in Shelburn, In are the best I've seen in a while. Being a former kitchen team member I look for... quality. And they are a 10 ... warmer case always topped with multiple choices each time I visit. Rob and his crew are friendlyand helpful. And I regularly let them know. ???? Keep up the great work guys! Read more
Pizza is ok. Not great. I love Casey's pizza just not here. They don't put much toppings on and the pizza is always a little... under cooked. Read more
Amazingly Friendly Customer Service with Friendly yet Professional Experience! ????? Keep up the Amazingness!
Was happy they had mug root beer in the fountain,,. So happy