Reviews for East of Chicago in Shelby, OH
Order was perfect! I got stuck in traffic and showed up a few minutes after close. I spoke with Blake on the phone to let him... know I was running a few minutes after close. Blake was extremely professional and so nice! Read more
Always friendly. Our pizza's are soooo yummy!
I live a mile down the road it took 40 min to get here my sub was warm not hot or fresh so if your expecting a hot pizza or hot... sub you may wanna warm up your oven to get hot!! Or just pick it up!! Read more
It's a hit or miss... will they answer the phone... Sometimes. They messed up my order twice. Their pizza is good only if you... get it with extra extra sauce. Without it and they mess up it's pretty bad... extra extra sauce makes this easily a recommendedpizza.. Never get anything above a large for some reason its thin and bad. Read more
I?m a trucker and I?ve traveled through many different states and tried many different pizzas. If you want the top of the line... stop at East of Chicago Pizza and you won?t be disappointed with anyone you stop at. Food is awesome and service is great. Thank you East of Chicago Pizza!!!~ Mark Matlock~ Read more
Horrible service and horrible food. Paid $2 for extra cheese on a small pizza and half of it didn?t even have cheese on it. The... ?cinnapops? weren?t even iced and they were hard when we picked them up at the time he said too. Also they had a grossartificial taste to them. We have heard from multiple not to go here but we decided to finally try it anyway and everyone wasright, they cheat you on toppings because they are cheap. Read more
I bought a large Taco Pizza from East of Chicago in Shelby, Ohio. It was Terrible!! Hardly any meat , the dough was still soft... (half baked) and the sauce was horrible. All I could taste was a strong Chili taste. I would NOT recommend this to anyone! Read more
Amazing pizza!! Always my first choice when ordering pizza and subs!