Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Shelbyville, KY
Our experience was awesome We loved it. We ordered 24 pieces of chicken wings ???? It was really well done ? Thank you Papa... John's team in Shelbyville. Read more
I had order the new papa bowls and they were awesome but other then my order getting messed up at first accidentally got a... cheese stick instead of the Meats bowl, But I called and told the manager, an immediately got it fixed and they were all veryhelpful in the store when I went to pick it up. I don't know there names but thank you and everything was hot and fresh Read more
We ordered the Philly CheeseSteak Papadias and some pepperoni pizzas. Great service as always. We love you guy.
This experience was so bad ! The worst ! I didn?t know this was well down for papa John! I called to places a complain. I talked... to the employee than the manager which both were okay nice, but once I got to talk to the boss. The boss was completely rude ! Itold him the pizza was burnt / black! He said thats how well done is & the pizza was probably brown not black! Than he continueto rudely told me to bring the pizza in because he won?t let a burnt pizza leave out the door! So I did take it ! He never facesme nor apologize nor speak to me . He never once talked to me ! He would speak to an employee & the employee would speak to me.Horrible costumer services from the boss ! I didn?t want to make a scene in the business which I didn?t but I was expecting arefund & my pizza made right! After I payed delivery plus tip! They remade it but just how the boss acted horrible!! Read more
Unbelievable that we order a pizza with 2 tops and 16 wings,no sauce and paid $50 dollars. We ordered the New York style for the... thin crust and got a thick crust along with the BITE SIZE wings. I will never recommend them nor ever return. Read more
3-1-22, ~8pm---PAY ATTENTION TO WHAT PEOPLE ORDER ONLINE!!!! 1/3 of our most recent ordered were up to par. The last order had... little cheese, so I ordered extra cheese this time to help make up for the last one lacking. I also ordered light sauce, and itcame oozing out of every piece! I'm literally having to squeeze sauce out of my pizza to eat it. We also ordered mediums, andthey came small and partially doughy. I've been eating this pizza for many years, and this is nothing like what I expect out ofPapa John's. We won't be back for a long while, and hopefully you'll hire someone who can actually make a proper Papa John'spizza! Read more
Second time I've ordered the Philly Cheesesteak PapaDias, with two Chicken, Ranch, Mushroom, and Black Olive covered pizzas!... Absolutely Delicious! I used to get Dominos, but they're nothing compared to Papa John's! Read more
Everyone is always so Pleasant and Kind. They stay extremely busy and still find a way to provide great customer service.