Reviews for Old Shell Store - Kitchen & Taphouse in Shell, WY

Very nice place. You order and pay at the counter, get a beeper, and pick up your food from the counter when it is done. The... dining room is pretty small but there is an option to sit outside under some large and gorgeous cottonwood trees. The food wasvery good. I have two things I did not like. I would like if they had better ventilation in the kitchen. The kitchen heated upthe entire building and it made the place a bit smokey. Also, I would like if they would put a clear coat of epoxy or somethingon their tables so it is a smooth surface. There were notches in the wood that food collected in. Over all I would go backagain. Read more

We got a brownie for later...oh MAN is it good! Burgers looked legit...if it wasn't for the catered lunch we would DEFINITELY... eat a burger here! Menu looked good and heard praises from others. Read more

This little place is what a buddy I remember the most from a 2-week camping trip. We were in the Badlands for a day, at Mount... Rushmore, through the Black Hills, touched the clouds and tasted the stars, yet spending an hour here really made an impressionupon us. Living in DC and my buddy hailing from Florida, we don't often get an opportunity to get to places where the vibe is somellow and welcoming. Couldn't have times it better with the amazing burgers and beer. The house picture is across from thetavern, yet it still caught our eye. Friendly chat with a few locals, really amazing warm people. Yes, I'll be back!! Read more

The Old Shell Store is a wonderful find. I had a beer and homemade banana bread. The banana bread was some of the best I've... ever had (and I've eaten my share). I'll return for more (and sample the burgers). Read more

I wanted a chicken sandwich but they don't serve them anymore. Went with the whiskey burger and I'm not quite sure why everyone... is touting the burgers on these reviews. Average at best. Decent size but low quality beef. And it was $15 Read more

Old shell store is the only store in shell. The food is good and prices fair. It's a wonderful place to have dinner or lunch.... Outside seating is very scenic, shaded, and comfy. You can buy beer and wine by the glass or package. Visit old shell store ifyou are camping west of Burgess junction on 14 in the big horns. Read more

I have dined at the Old Shell store a couple times. The first was because it was recommended, the second was because it is so... awesome! I have tried the Whiskey Burger and the Jalapeno Burger and they were both great! Their naked goods are fresh, largeand delicious. And, if you like a cold draft beer with your meal, they have a great selection! Read more

A great selection of drinks, a cinnamon roll that was excellent, and an apple tart that was seriously to die for! The staff was... really helpful and super nice. Highly recommend this exceptionally cute country stop over! Read more