Reviews for Piesano's Pizzeria and Restaurant in Shelter Island, NY

So happy these new owners are here! Best pizza we had in a very long time! Perfectly cooked crust, excellent sauce and a nice... amount of cheese! Plus, the place is spotlessly clean! Can't wait to go back and try the sausage roll that my brother-in-lawsaid was awesome! Tonights special was $12 a pie! (They had a few different specials for the week) A home run! Read more

Overall a good place but the pizza is either decent or absolutely terrible. The people seem nice and I hate to do this but they... have disappointed me too many times. Also the pepperoni pinwheels are always obnoxiously small when in the display in thecounter they appear much larger and sometimes too dry to even eat. Read more

Great pizza!

Amazing calzones and decent prices. Best pizza in town since Primo.

New owners here. Original owners weren't the greatest, so that's a nice change. Right off the bat they fixed the door, cleaned... the place real well, painted the place. Really spruced it up, although the old owners weren't there long they didn't putanything into it, new owners really is a nice job. Friendly staff inside. Highly recommend. I didn't see if they had a lunchspecial, like two slices and a soda for a fixed price, I'll check next time. Read more