Reviews for Gilligan's Island in Sherburne, NY
My husband, three kids and I have made Gilligan?s part of our weekend. We get lunch or dinner and ice cream. It?s usually tasty.... Last time we went, the college kids from Colgate ruined our experience with their loudness and entitlement. This time, our foodwas not even warm. Stone cold. And this was after I waited at least a half an hour. I went up to check on it because theyweren?t busy, was told it was almost done, and then it was literally ice cold. I?m rethinking our weekend tradition. It costs us$55 for a cold dinner. Read more
As a Vermont vegan I search high and low for ice cream wherever I go...this place has some of the best vegan ice cream in North... America! Their flavors are robust and their vegan ice creams are creamy from start to finish. A medium cone of this qualitywill cost easily double or triple in most places. A welcome treat oasis in upstate NY. Wahoo! Read more
My wife and I have been going to Gilligan's usually once a weekend for a burger, fries, soda, and ice cream afterwards. We often... order one of their liquor flavored cakes for a party. It's a nice treat going there. The caveat is....that when you order aburger you are asked to pull to the parking lot and one of the young girls brings the order to your car. It seemed that over thepast several months the food was coming out cold. A couple of weeks ago, my wife and I waited for 40 minutes for our meal. Ifinally drove over to the window to see where our order was. The young girl asked if I had an order number....they never give anorder number or receipt. I told them that if they could not supply the food, that I would want my money back. After all, $27.00for two burger meals is no bargain. I was told that the girl who took our order went home and did not tell anyone. They askedthat I park and they would bring out a new order. They did, in a timely manner, and refunded our money besides. Now, I would ofnever have brought this up except, yesterday my wife and I went there and ordered our usual. We waited again about 40 minutes. Iwas just about to go back to the window, when the girl came to my car with our order. She must of drew the short straw to be theone to bring us our meal. She appeared distraught as she handed it over and hesitantly told us that our order was misplaced. Sonow for $27.00 we had a COLD burger and fries....hardly appetizing on a cool fall afternoon. The owners of Gilligan's are hardworkers. I am sure that they would not want their customers treated this way. I implore them to be more aware of their employeesactions and hopefully implement a system from preventing this from happening again. If I was to have another incident such asthis, I would think my business with Gilligan's would be in jeopardy. Read more
I got a soft serve twist cone, so I can't comment on the food. They were very quick with my order. Everything as expected. The... serving size was generous. I will be back...???? Read more
First time ever I got a very bad meal from this place , normally I give this place 5 stars or even higher stars but the night of... sept 29 it was Terrible. The 4 orders of burgers were cooked wrong, the four orders of ff were like way over cooked ( we aretalking about hard as Rocks) and I also paid for ex mayo for ff and did not get it . Which I guess was fine because all of us Fed the wildlife on the way home with just the fies. Than another Customer saw that I was waiting for a long time and she askedif I was forgot and than they did not even know what or where my order was . So I give the girl my recipe back so she could findmy order and than when I got my order I asked for receipt back and the other girl Throw my receipt in the trash or something.So the Original girl wrote me a handwritten receipt which is not what I wanted but it was what I got . Read more
They have such good, homemade hamburgers! I had the Bigger than the Island hamburger and it was huge and amazing ???? Now if... you?ll excuse me, I?m getting myself a shake! Read more
They make their own ice cream. I got the soft serve, I'm usually a hard ice cream lover only. But this twist peaked my interest,... black raspberry and peach soft serve. Only con is that they only have one type of cone. Read more
It was very nice here. The staff was friendly and pretty efficient. The burger (Bacon Rancher Burger) and fries that I had was... delicious. I will certainly be back again. Read more