Reviews for Old Mill Tavern in Sheridan, IL
Great food and Atmosphere! Per 4 and 6 year Olds they have the best ranch ever here.
Small town tavern, family atmosphere. Locally owned and operated. Fantastic menu,fair prices. Great staff!
Service was very good as it always is. Food was great. We highly recommend the Alaskan cod.
Just like old times. Delicious! Excellent service.
Fish Fry very good. Fresh oil. Must see around Christmas. Fantastic decorations. The back of the bar is a large village scene... that covers the entire back of the bar. As of publication January 22 decorations still there. 25 minutes drive from Holiday InnFox River. About 8 stairs. Unsure if entry without stair. Call and ask any question, even busy they answer. Read more
We always go on Saturday for "all u can eat Crappie". Its fried to perfection - never greasy. Gabby is our favorite waitress and... she does her job well. We love going this time of year so we can see their holiday decorations. Read more
The Place The Old Mill Tavern is located in Sheridan, Illinois not to far off RT71 and by the Fox river. This is an... authentic... old country restaurant complete with yesteryear memorabilia, plastic table cloths and even has an old fashionedclaw arcade game. The Menu/Food The menu is your classic bar menu featuring some breading recipes from the 40's. Lets face it,not everyday do you see a menu offering a complete liver or gizzard dinner. I've been at the tavern for several of theirnightly specials including the Tuesday Night Steak Fry and Wednesday Taco Night. There are also several all you can eatspecials. The Steak Fry is fun and the food was good. The taco salad is good and the taco's are as well. TheExperience/Service/Value This is a great change of pace place. Our service was a little slow but it was steady. I ordered amixed drink and there was no complaining about the pour. You can't beat the value!! Give them a try. Read more
Another small mom and pop operation. Good food. They are cash only.