Reviews for Silver City Pizza in Sherrill, NY
Best pizza around. The house sauce is the bomb!
Pizza improved greatly a few months back, from nearly inedible to AMAZING! Turned out a new 'owner' took over around that time,... which was the cause of such a positive change. They are now closed for 'renovations', which apparently includes the previousowner taking the shop back. This quickly became our favorite pizza shop, not only for pizza, but for subs, fish fry, pasta, etc.Everything on the menu was fantastic! With the new owner taking over one of two things will happen; 1.) he returns to the samegarbage recipes or 2.) he steals the new from the gentleman that worked so hard to bring the place to where it is now. In eithercase, that is, in my opinion, shady business that I will have no part of. My family spent $60 - $100 there which we will nowtake somewhere else. Read more
Top notch Pizzeria! The staff is so friendly. We were given a topping for free and extra sauce at no charge. The Pizza Shop is... not stingy and will go out of their way to make sure the customer is happy! Thank you for your generous and friendly service.The pizza is amazing here! Read more
Pizza could use better crust, but the sauce is the best around compared to Pepi's and New York Pizzeria. Their subs and other... selections such as chicken riggies are great. They also offer a much better selection then New York Pizzeria. Read more
Was pretty good