Reviews for East of Chicago Pizza of Shinnston in Shinnston, WV
I?m a vegetarian, and I asked for a stuffed crusted cheese pizza with zero meat. And told them I was a vegetarian and the put... pepperoni in the crust. I did not see it and I ate a piece after TWO YEARS of not eating meat. I?m very upset. Read more
Not a great pizza place. The food is very good, however they rarely give you what you order. They constantly mess up my order... but usually do work to fix it but it becomes annoying when I order items with no modification and its still made wrong. It isalso quite expensive. On the positive side the owner and employees are very nice and the store is kept very clean. Read more
The Chicago style crust is well worth the $22! One of the best deep dish spots in WV!
Ordered 3 different occasions from the Shinnston location hoping for a better experience. Terrible all 3 times and with the... price it comes with it shouldn?t be. Absolutely would rather choose other pizza shops than this one in town. Read more
Ordered the chicago style once before, dough was not done under the toppings. Called and they replaced it. Dough was still not... done right. The rest of the food was great. Don't think we are going to order the chicago style pizza again. Will order foodfrom them, like I said the other food was great. Read more
The pan pizza with pepperoni is the bomb. Best pizza I've ever had. Love how cheese is on top of pepperoni. Def a slice of... heaven ???? Read more
I'm giving 4 stars because the pizza is outstanding. Not hot because the wait was long. The pricing was confusing and... miscommunicated and the order was incorrect at first. I'm confused by the 5 star rating also given that before me, there were 5reviews, 4 of which are 1 star, which I understand, given the absolute terrible job done of getting us the correct food at thecorrect price. The ONE thing done anywhere near well is the making of pizza. The pizza is stellar!! I can't wait to try thisplace again and hope for a much MUCH better front end experience. I also find it unsatisfying that it's showing a 5 star ratingwhen they have 4 one star ratings and 1 five star rating. That doesn't seem right. However, I hope to change it to 5 stars on mynext visit. Amazing pizza. Possibly the best around? We will see. Read more
This is one of my favorite chain pizza places.