Reviews for Bagel Pantry in Short Hills, NJ
Nice little bagel shop in our neighborhood. Great food, great prices and nice indoor and outdoor seating. Plus a jazz band... playing outside on Father's Day! Read more
Amazing bagels, delicious cream cheese. Yummy egg sandwiches. Excellent customer service.
We're pretty sure our sausage breakfast bagels were just hot dogs cut in half... Bagels were awesome, service was great;... perhaps we should have asked about what kind of sausage meat before we placed an order. Read more
Great place. Great food. Very good bagels. Pretty much everything they have is of good quality. Owner is a very good man as... well. Read more
Breakfast sandwich was fine. Nothing special. Have they heard of Breakfast sausage? I did not want hot dog with my eggs. Also,... missing cheese though I watched cashier write SEC Read more
Fantastic bagels (the best since I moved out of Brooklyn). They also make great sandwiches (the Philly cheesesteak with cheddar... on a whole wheat wrap was excellent, and my 4 year old loved their grilled cheese with American and cheddar). The service isfriendly and fast, too, they?re super efficient and very nice. Not to mention great prices, too. I love this place. Read more
I ordered a French toast platter with turkey bacon. The bacon was over cooked and the French toast did not fully taste... like...well...French toast. In my opinion, it needed a lot more cinnamon/vanilla extract. It tasted like lightly seasonedchallah bread, not enough crisp and very thick and bready. Read more
First time patron. Got in at 10 am. Bagels were fresh , warm fluffy, and absolutely delicious. Place was clean and staff was... courteous . Just for that 5 stars Read more