Reviews for Amelio's Pizzeria in Sidney, OH
Pepperoni Amore was exactly what I was craving. Bartender was extremely friendly and the drinks were strong. Wish I lived here,... would be my go to place! Read more
Awesome old world Italian food! Great atmosphere with an old meets new cozy kind of vibe. They make their own marinara and it... shows. Homemade pizza crust with fresh toppings. Freshly cut mozzarella wrapped in a wonton wrapper and fried is their newtake on a boring old cheese stick, and it is good! Especially when dipped in some leftover garlic sauce from the homemadegarlic knots! Toni (the owner) is a sweetheart and the pride she takes in her family heritage shows. Read more
Our waitress was super sweet and good at her job. My family enjoyed their pasta. I got the stuffed cheese manicotti type dish.... For me personally, it wasn't my favorite. The ends of the noodles were hard and the ricotta cheese stuffing was tasteless. Onceagain, I'm sure it's just my own opinion as it's my first time trying that dish. I've had the one of the pizzas before and itwas good. The atmosphere is great there and I probably will come back again and try something else. Read more
Great experience! I'm thankful they took reservations so we could get seated as soon as we got there. The stuffed mushrooms were... the best I've ever had! We tried pizza and lasagna and both were fantastic. Great atmosphere & service. Read more
I definitely recommend the Italian Stallion sandwich. It was quite tasty, but beware that the bread is crusty and will do a... number on the roof of your mouth. The side salad is small, but mighty, especially with the Parmesan Peppercorn dressing. Supersatisfying! The peach mimosa was delicious, especially the caramel cinnamon drizzle on the glass. The atmosphere is festive andfun, but noticably loud. Overall, we enjoyed our dinner and will come back again. Read more
Love the atmosphere. We were the only one there lol which was nice with two two year Olds. We got a pepperoni with house made... sauce and mozz ch. The sauce was delicious and it was super cheesy. The only reason it's not 5 stars cause for the addiontionalprice to get pepperoni there wasn't very much. Read more
Wow. Just wow. This place is AMAZING to say the least. Service was amazing! Every worker I encountered was friendly and had a... smile on their face. As for the food? SO GOOD!! I got a sub (so did my boyfriend) and it was delicious. We couldn?t stop talkingabout how great our subs were. I mean they were just the right temperature and taste. The bread was soft but yet crunchy on theoutside. The thing practically melted in my mouth it was so good! And the fries?. Oh boy the fries were like no other. I askedfor ketchup at first (creature of habit) but I ended up not even needed it because the taste of the fries alone were amazing.Everything was awesome and I can?t wait to go back! Way to go amelio?s! Read more
Just got back from dinner at Amelio?s. Ordered the Veggie pizza. After 35 mins got a pizza with fully uncooked veggies. The... mushrooms were only warm (totally uncooked) and the onion was absolutely raw. Requested the pizza be put into the oven again-got home to find the onions with tips slightly burnt but overall still raw ?! If we are going to pay $30 for a pizza, I thinkit?s fair to expect it to be cooked not raw.. Read more