Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Sidney, OH
Ordered a pizza at 12:13 midnight on 4/2/22. Was told It would be delivered in 2 hours. It's now 2 am. And I've not received my... pizza. This is absolutely Unacceptable. Take my money and not deliver what I paid for. Read more
Ordered a delivery and after 2 hours called to see what was going on and the staff had no idea what I was talking about, Staff... is extremely rude and racist. Would never recommend this place to anyone on this earth. Read more
Ordered from work.put specific instructions deliver WEST SIDE. WAREHOUSE. Was left at the guardhouse OUTSIDE ON THE SIDEWALK!!!... Over $20 worth of food ya think you'd get better service. Wont order from here ever again Read more
Don?t ask me for a tip. I had a delivery driver just come here to drop off a pizza and he asked me do I want to put a tip on... there for him. First of all, I always tip the delivery drivers, but when he asked me it got up under my skin. I paid more than$4 for a delivery charge, I paid the company and the company pays him hourly to do their deliveries. Do we pay UPS tips? Do wetip Amazon deliverers? I tip because that?s the norm and to make the workers happy, but I don?t have to do it and to be honestit doesn?t make sense. I paid the price for my food, tips are extra gratuities typically earned when someone does somethingabove and beyond. All these pizza places are asking for tips before we even taste the food, how do we know if they even deservea tip??? I worked for years earning less than delivery drivers doing much harder work at farms, I survived without tips. Workersshould never ask for a tip. I was gonna give him more than the usual $10 because it?s Christmas Eve, but since he asked for oneI gave him $7. Have some manners, or next time someone asks me for a tip I?m gonna say no. Read more
I ordered a pizza almost 2 hours ago while.im at work and it still has not showed up and gave them specific instructions to call... me when they got here and not only did I pay for the pizza with a card I didnt get a phone call and now I cant even call themcause there closed. What is the point in asking for specific instructions if they dont follow them and now I'm at work withoutlunch way to go Papa John's.... Read more
They have great pizza with quality ingredients. They are very quick here. The dough is thick and fluffy, but they also serve a... thin-style crust. Jalapeno popper rolls are tasty and their chicken wings are decent: buffalo, bbq, honey chipotle, or unsauced.I have not tried their "papadias", which is basically a foldover. They do look delicious, offering five styles: grilled buffalochicken, Italian, bbq chicken bacon, or philly cheesesteak, or meatball pepperoni. All three desserts are not bad actually:cinnamon pull aparts, chocolate chip cookie, or chocolate chip brownie. Read more
Quick service, good food. This time though they did not bring my drink and I had to wait for them to return. It's an... inconvenience with an infant and stairs to go up and down. Update. Ordered hot wings with ranch and brownies 6/28 and got noranch (this is the second time they haven't brought dip/sauce). I called and they said that someone would be right out with itand no one ever showed up. It's been 40 minutes. I probably won't be ordering from this location anymore. They showed up at11:12 PM. One hour and one minute after I called. I did not answer. Why? Because I just put my 7 month old son to bed. Read more
Rated 3 stars because it's hit or miss with this store. Last time was great but the time before undercooked and doughy.