Reviews for Sierra Madre Pizza Company in Sierra Madre, CA

Came here on a whim because I was craving pizza. Got the lunch special with a slice of pepperoni, a salad, and a small drink.... Reasonably priced and the food was fresh and delicious. Staff was friendly and food came out quickly. Will be returning to trysome of the other menu items. Read more

Good pizza, good ingredients and average crust. Close to The Buccaneer my new favorite local place, even though I?m not a local

Great people serving fantastic pizza in Sierra Madre. What a superb local restaurant

The best pizza in Sierra. Are hands down been going there what my mom and dad since a kid always warm always tasty a wonder... crust and even better pepperoni lol Read more

easily the best pizza spot in the SGV. the food quality is always amazing, the serving size is beyond gracious, the prices are... insanely affordable, and the ownership and staff team are always so pleasant and helpful. took me way too long to find thisplace and now me and whole family can't get enough! veggie calzone is my ultimate go to! Read more

Ordered a pizza, pasta and garlic bread through Übereats. Everything was very good! Only subpar thing was the pizza crust.... Little to no flavor; just not quite right. But we hope to give it another few tries. Read more

We ordered a large cheese Pizza and a extra large olive and mushroom pizza. The pizzas were excellent but when we called, the... phone service was a bit 4 star wanky. The person who answered did not give the name of the company. Then proceeded to argue thatthere was no website. Which we were looking at at the time. But the pizza was ready on time we just went in got the pizza andhad some great pizza. I will definitely try them again and see if we can add in that extra star. :-) Read more

Reasonably priced, excellent customer service. The only difference is that I like a thinner crust. This one tends to be on the... thicker side almost bread-like, not like a thin New York style. But generally it's a decent, good tasting pizza. Read more