Reviews for Tomacelli's Pizza & Pasta in Sioux Falls, SD
Typical low class pizza and place I personally don't eat there anymore as they have gone down hill big time . Pizza is greasy as... he'll and there salad has changed since like 10 years ago when you used to get more items on salad but not anymore maybe becauseof pandemic but still not worth price for less. The other thing that really bothers me and my husband is the inside looks likea cockroach infested slumlord place that needs major painting and updating , guess owner don't care so thus my family won't begoing here to eat or go inside . I pray that owner of this place can change it around for the near future but so far not sogood. Sorry Read more
Fun spot decorated with the graffiti of its customers...fair prices and above average pies! Could not give it more than a 3 for... service as due to staffing shortages you had to order at the server window. Would definitely go back! Read more
One of our favorite pizza places in Sioux Falls is Tomicellis! Our go to dinner from there is the Spartichoke Pizza that comes... with feta, spinach, artichokes, roma tomatoes, olive oil, and garlic. I highly recommend throwing some cholua on it for someextra razzle dazzle! If that's not your style they have many other options to choose from along with pastas, desert, andappetizers. If you're craving pizza and don't want the usual franchise chains we highly recommend this local pizza spot, the oneon the west side is very unique when you go inside but has a certain charm to it and somewhat reminds me of the old pizza placesback when I was a kid, especially when someone is playing the arcade game up by the order window. Read more
Old time, old school! Reminds of a restaurant you'd see in a movie where Thugs ran the place. Lol. But, don't let the looks... deceive you. The food and service were worth everything and anything you may have thoughts of. The parking lot, although smalland hard to park, was full! A continuous flow of people getting to-go orders. Don't leave without getting a salad. But plan onsharing with two or three people. Bring a marker, you might decide to use it! Read more
This place is fantastic ! I ordered from them while I stayed in Sioux Falls for a few days. I'm in love with the cheese and... pepperoni pizza they make called THE SUPER PEPPERONI ! The sauce is sweet, great flavor, seasoned right and they put a perfectamount on. They really pack this thing with pepperoni and if you want some delicious pie, do it ! I also had their hot chickenWings. Super good! Temperature very hot, meat fell off the bone easily and had a good, spicy but really good taste sauce onthem. Awesome and very fairly priced. Then to top it off, had some of their delicious cheesecake slices for dessert ???? ????mmmm mmmm good ! I will ALWAYS order from here when I'm in town, no doubt! Thank you to all the staff there and the awesomedelivery drivers who brought the food to my room at my hotel. You guys rock ! Thank you for the really good food and service,you all are wonderful, sincerely! Thank you for making me feel at home with some hot food. Read more
We only patronize 2 pizza places. It's been like that for YEARS (10+)....This isn't glassdoor but I know behind the scenes and... didn't care for working here BUT..............EATING is a WHOLE NEW BALL GAME! I wonder if y'all sitll got that black and whitesweater in the back? Excellent customer service on phone. Knew the specials. A wonderful welcome. Food IS always excellent forus...rarely...maybe once I can say a pizza was a tiny bit doughy but I get the oven and opening of doors during busy hours andextra cheese can cause this.... Now if only we can get the rest of the world to understand restaurant businesses and how to bemore patient with you all. Read more
Ordered 16? w/ green peppers and mushrooms for delivery. The guy on the phone also delivered my pizza and was super cool. Proper... ferment and bake is evident on the dough, enough gluten to give it body and a bit of chewiness but without being tough. Toppingswere fresh and plentiful. I?ve now had three Sioux Falls pizzas in as many weeks and #2 is distant to Tomacelli?s, the clearvictor. Highly recommended. Read more
First time visit, not very busy for Monday night, had the place to ourselves in the dining room. Reviews that we read were... helpful. Pizza was very good. Short staffed, so you sat yourself, got your own plates, ordered at the takeout window. It's allgood. Oh yeah, be sure to leave your mark on the wall. Graffiti walls ! Read more