Reviews for Door County Creamery in Sister Bay, WI
It took us a few tries navigating their open hours (kitchen closes at 7!) to finally get our hands on the Turkey Brie sandwich,... but it was well worth it! The ice cream is amazing too. Read more
Fantastic ice cream made from goats milk. No lactose in goats milk which is great for the lactose intolerant people like myself... ????; lots of other goat milks products like cheese and soap Read more
Fantastic place to stop for lunch in Sister Bay! Good selections and a wonderful option for vegetarians. Dishes were $14 each... and well worth it. Finishing lunch with gelato is a must! Standard and unexpectedly fun flavors too. Read more
Love! Great for gifts, quick gelato treat, fresh cheese curds!
Adorable shop with the best treats!!! The cookies are to die for. Loved the homegoods they had. The whole shop was so charming.... Sandwiches were so tasty. Fun spot to get snacks and wine for a picnic. Read more
We tried three different kinds of gelato and loved them all. They also have a small shop with local cheeses and gifts as well as... sandwiches. Read more
When at sisters Bay you have to eat at Door County Creamery. They don't have too many selection of ice creams but the flavors... they have taste great. We had Various ice creams but really liked Door County Cheery and Ultimate Oreo. However if you can havejust one then you have get Chocolate Raspberry Truffle. This is the best flavor they have. Read more
I arrived hungry so didn?t get the gelato but got the fall Caesar salad which was, I kid you not, one of the top two salads I?ve... had in my life. The salad was huge (which we were told) so we split it between 2-4 of us and it was outstanding. I?d come backagain just for that salad. Top notch. Well done Door Country Creamery! Read more