Reviews for New World Pizza & Cafe in Skillman, NJ

Guys here are making good pizza. Brooklyn is top. There full slice like a Supreme with all fixens was done Rite

Recently recommended by a show host from NJ101.5 radio (regarding cheesesteaks). We had a terrible pizza years ago and said... what the heck we'd give this a try for the cheesesteaks. Save your money. Both cheesesteaks were dry. Rolls were nothingspecial. We asked for onions, mushrooms and extra cheese. They gave us a few measly uncooked onions and no mushrooms andhardly any cheese. There was an extra 4% credit card fee! We paid over $41. Never again. Read more

This is a very popular local pizza restaurant. Staff was friendly. Pizza was good.

New World Pizza discriminates!! They suddenly stopped delivering to an apartment building in Skillman because of experience with... a bad tenant. Now the whole building of 100+ people are being punished. Why can?t they blacklist people instead? Very unfair. Read more

Now charges a 4% credit card fee. Pizzas are also now close to $19 excluding the fee. Very very overpriced. I can get a pie for... $15 the town over and they don?t charge a credit card fee. Read more

$19.45 and they don?t even cover the whole pie with cheese ????????

Great food & great service! This place has been a favorite of ours for years. So happy they offer gluten free options... too! One thing -- DO NOT order thru slice or another 3rd party, just call them directly. Read more

Good food, much better than when we first moved here over 13 years ago. Delivery takes FOREVER, I don't bother with that... anymore. If you order ahead for pickup, the times are what you expect for a pizza place I this area. 20ish minutes for a typicalpizza order, maybe 30-40 if they are busy, and I'm glad to see them busy. Busy times are when you expect - dinner/lunch, more soon weekends. And that's typical, a pizza takes about 20 minutes to make and you can only fit so many pies plus other menu itemsin at one time. I like their website, and the order is always accurate. Prices are up lately, but my grocery bill is up, it'sjust the cost of ingredients going up, so that's not actually a minus on them, just an observation. Not the friendliest staff, Ithink that flows from the owner/GM. His demeanor may be especially affected by getting the business profitable again. I think heis very tough on making sure every extra is charged for. I get that, it's a business, not a charity. I'm VERY glad they arestill in business. So to conclude good food, website good, don't do delivery unless you are ordering 2 hours ahead. Read more