Reviews for Bottoms Up Restaurant and Pub in Slate Hill, NY
Went here last year for my birthday and loved it. Great food great service. Returned for birthday this year . Made reservation... for table of 2. Arrived and was seated at worst possible table next to kitchen. When asked for better table was told they werebooked but place was empty and then sat us in another room with a 2 top table but told 2 parties of 4 arriving at 7. It was only5pm! So now we felt rushed. Steak was very overcooked , scallops were all cooked differently one looked raw. Potato thing was sosalty could not eat it! Clams on half shell were significantly different sizes and only got 7 on plate. The same flourless cakethat was so good last year was a mere tiny sliver and i mean tiny! I know times are tough right now this was so disappointing!While the waitress was great this will more than likely be my last time here. Read more
We had a wonderful lunch today at Bottoms Up, Slate Hill, NY. Upon arrival we were greeted professionally and pleasantly by... Jossie. This experience continued through our entire lunch. We were very pleased with our lunch and certainly will return toenjoy the excellent food and service. Thank you Read more
Went on a Tuesday for girls night. Caitlin & Erin were amazing I had the zucchini flowers and Greek salad - delicious!!!
What a pleasant experience dining at this beautiful restaurant. The staff were amazing and very welcoming. Our waitress was very... helpful and knowledgeable. Food was really fresh. Very well priced. Love this restaurant! We will definitely be back. Read more
My first time going to this restaurant and definitely the last. Service was mediocre at best, I ordered the broiled Halibut... Bruschetta, the food was cold, tasless,the veggies overcooked and mushy and the bruschetta sauce tasted and looked old. Myfriends both ordered the shrimp scampi, their food was cold enough that they couldn't eat either. The waitress came to our tableonce. She was not enthusiastic about making any suggestions on their evening specials or the wine list. Couldn't get out fastenough. Read more
We are repeat customers. Seated immediately. Our waitress was wonderful! great food! Great service! We all had the Root beer... chicken sandwich...the table next to us saw what we had...they ordered the same thing!!! Would definitely get it again! Wewill definitely come back! Read more
Always great service, food and atmosphere. Big private party room. One of our favorite places to relax and have dinner and a... drink. Was delicious Read more
I have been frequenting Bottoms Up for many years and was always pleased . On my recent visit 11/19/22 I ordered the ... Scallops Carbonara which I've had many times and love. I should have returned my meal. The scallops were gritty and soundercooked that I only ate two of them. A few hours later I was so sick, broke out in a cold sweat with nausea, vomiting.stomach pain and chills . To say I am disappointed is an understatement. Read more