Reviews for Coffaro's Pizza in Slippery Rock, PA
Really enjoyed the all meat pizza. Great tasting dough too
So good!! First time ordering there today. We got pizza, bread sticks, and a buffalo chicken salad. Love that it was on shredded... lettuce! The buffalo sauce was mild but flavorful. Hubs likes the pizza! We ordered online, got delivery, and it was a few minsbehind the requested time, but still fresh and good. :) Read more
This place is a staple for pizza in slippery rock. Great prices and portions. You won't be disappointed.
I am a truck driver so I have had my share of pizza around the country, but the pizza BY FAR is the best I have ever had in my... life. Plus the staff is super friendly. This place is a most stop and eat. Read more
I enjoy coffaros pizza, I have given them many opportunities, but I am not happy with their quality of their pizza lately I have... ordered many pizzas now and asked for extra cheese each time which you guys charge for and every time I'm disappointed, thecheese should go to the edge of the crust and when you ask for extra there should be extra im done ordering pizza from you guys.Tonight I ordered a pepperoni pizza with extra cheese not only does it not have extra cheese but the cheese is very skimped onand the Dough is not completely cooked!! Just ordered pizza tonight 06/27/22 once again I made the mistake of giving this placeyet another chance and I am disappointed! When you pay for extra cheese you should get extra cheese and when you are solely apizza place you should fully cook your pizza each and every time! Read more
Best local pizza! Plus the owners are wonderful people. It's so nice that they bought the bowling alley several years ago so... that we all could continue to enjoy it. Read more
We just relocated to the area recently and have ordered a few times now. Pizza is always very tasty. Last night the order got a... little mixed up with bacon instead of pepperoni. I called and told them the mistake which normally is a stressful experience forme but they were very kind about making it right for me. We will definitely be back again and again. Read more
Wow. Terrific pizza. Crust is crispy and tender inside. Toppings are fresh and not baked-to-death. Quick service. Late hours.... Everything you want in a college town pizza joint. Read more