Reviews for Carrabba's Italian Grill in Smithtown, NY
Wonderful experience at this location. I know it's a chain but at this Long Island location, it's really more intimate and... comfortable. The staff here is incredible and we loved our server. The food was divine, especially the new fall menu items. Thefontina/prosciutto stuffed pork chops were out of this world. Don't even get me started on the cinnamon applecheesecake.....WOW. Top to bottom this was an amazing experience and I can't wait to come back here for another Italian dinner. Read more
No wait to be seated. Really good Chicken Soup, stuffed mushrooms but the bread with dipping oil is good enough to eat as a... meal. Very enjoyable night out to celebrate my daughters 22nd Birthday. Read more
After a long day of moving our son in to college we decided to have dinner as a family before heading back home. We are so glad... we stopped by Carrabba?s. We were served by the sweetest most attentive waitress, Amber. She served us promptly and wasattentive to us without overwhelming us. I will definitely be back when I come visit my son. P.S: The pomegranate Martini was ahit ???????? Read more
We always love coming to Carrabbas in Smithtown. The food here is always amazing and the staff is awesome! Eileen was our server... tonight and she was amazing and very attentive we never had an empty drink! Our food came out promptly and hot! Read more
This was my first time at Carrabba?s and I loved it! Food was great, atmosphere was great. I told the host Julia I wanted to sit... at the bar she led me there with menus and was so friendly. The bartender, Kristy was great! She had great conversation andexplained the menu to me and what some her favorites were. She told me to get the Filet Johnny with Lobster Ravioli and she didnot steer me wrong! Had the bread pudding for dessert- it was so good. Another server, Gerry brought the dessert out to me andwas so friendly as well. The environment was very welcoming - you just made yourself a new regular! Read more
I have a 100% great experience every time I go here. The prices are definitely reasonable for the excellent food you get. The... food is absolutely delicious - I really love their chicken soup which is one of the best I've ever had - along with all theirother well prepared Italian dishes. The ambiance is perfect - fun bar area with quiet sit-down dinner area as well. Nicedecor. Phenomenal staff - on our last visit, Michelle and Billy were extremely attentive and friendly and did not miss a singlething! I come back here almost every time I visit back to NY - and my family and I love it. They really do everything right. Read more
This was the second time we had curbside delivery this year. It was about 8:30 pm last night (Thursday). They're online ordering... is one of the quickest & easiest compared to many other restaurants. We didn't order much this time. One of the items was a new"Spring" appetizer of mozzarella and tomatoes. The price was under $11. during one of the highest inflation-times that I've everexperienced. I even ordered a gluten-free pasta dinner without protein (meat). Again, that was about $15 and could easily feedtwo adults. We just began to ease into a gluten-free diet, I wasn't that excited about the pasta until I tasted it. I'm prettysure the pasta was homemade by the restaurant, because it was absolutely fantastic. I want to thank everyone that workedCarrabba's in Smithtown last night. ***Especially, the person who packaged our order!! They included a good amount of bread &lots of extras. Everything was perfect. From easy online ordering, being ready quickly and right on time. The food was excellentand so was the service. We'll be going back quite often!!! Thank you!! KH Smithtown NY Read more
Amazing service. Our waiter Derrek H was great, paced our apps, salad, meal. Very friendly and out going . Extremely pleased... with the service. Food was great as always. Thanks for such great service Derrek ???????????????? Read more