Reviews for Old Street Restaurant and Bar in Smithtown, NY
We were just looking for cocktails (2 people) and a burger, not gourmet, so a friend suggested Old Street. Ample parking is a... plus and we walked in and sat at the bar which is where you land when you first enter. This was a slow time, so we can't commenton service when it is busy. Christina was behind the bar and provided pleasant assistance. The slightly worn, old school vibe ofthe place was comfortable for us. We had a straight burger platter which was huge and it came with fries, Cole slaw and pickles,and our other order was for a liverwurst & onions on rye that was a special, served with potato salad (great), slaw and pickles.The dishes were delicious, well prepared and abundant. A couple of pumpkin martinis and an IPA finished us off with no hope ofroom for desert. This is now on our list of places to revisit. Read more
Never a bad experience in twenty years of eating here. There's a real nostalgic sort of warmth to the place, and the bar pours... excellent drinks. Read more
I need to look into ordering a supply of that salmon with the dill topping, it was absolutely incredible. I attended a bridal... shower here and was quite pleased with the restaurant. From the menu to the atmosphere, everything was just lovely. AlthoughI did not try the " fried bread and cheese" dish that was on the table, many were bragging about the taste. I did not have therolls either but they seemed to be gone quite quickly. Those who decided to order the steak or chicken also seemed delightedwith their meals. The folks who were spending time at the bar were happy, friendly, and enjoying their Saturday afternoon. Ispoke with a few of the guests and they said that this place was fun and comfortable. I would definitely recommend stopping byand if you wouldn't mind.....please pick up a tray of the salmon for me. Read more
Old Street is a Great place to meet with friends for nice meal. I always get a burger here. The condiments that come with the... burger are a starter of beer cheese and toast chips, coleslaw and pickles. I?ve been going here over 25 years, neverdisappointed. Read more
Meh.... food was not good. Ordered the Beer Battered Fish and Chips, French Onion Soup and Buffalo Cauliflower. The fish was not... that fresh, the batter was strangely thick and super greasy. The chips tasted old and had this weird sweetness to them. Took afew bites and couldn?t finish it. The French Onion Soup had an extra thick layer of cheese that you could not pull away from thebowl and was hard to eat. I was not a fan of the flavor of the soup either. The Buffalo Cauliflower was a special. Cold (allthe food was cold tbh) and soggy. The server was friendly, but never asked me if anything was wrong when she saw I only ate acouple of bites of my meal. The place was clean and the tables were well spaced. It?s a shame about the food, but unfortunatelyI probably won?t give it a second chance. Read more
Food is delicious. The bread and cheese they give you (pictured) is almost too good. We could?ve eaten a few plates of it. I got... the stuffed shrimp and it was a big, tasty portion Overall great experience here. Read more
NY Steak was okay.,vegetables were cold. Eggnog Martini was delicious. They know how to make cocktails. And the carrot cake was... good. The atmosphere was very nice but honestly not worth the price and the food was average at best. Read more
We were a party of 4 for lunch. No wait for a table though the restaurant began to fill up. The menu was vast so we all found... something to try. It was nice to see that a regular burger was 1/2 lb. and was served with fries, onion rings and Cole slaw. Our waiter was attentive though he did forget a couple of items. Food portions were good and everyone enjoyed. There were nogames for paying with a credit card. I'm sure we wouldn't hesitate to dine here again. Read more