Reviews for Sal's of Smithtown in Smithtown, NY
I got a bbq chicken slice around 6:30/7:00 pm. In the middle of the night I was throwing up and had the runs really bad. I would... not recommend sals. Thumbs down for me. Read more
Sal's of Smithtown on Terry Road has delicious food and their service is friendly and efficient! My favorite slices are the... chicken caesar and ravioli. The owner Sal is a great guy. 5 stars! Read more
Came here for the 5 stars and to see what's all the fuss about Sals of Smithtown. I ordered a vodka chicken cutlet hero with... fresh mozz. It took 45 minutes to make when I was told 25. That's not the worse part. They give it cold as anything and thefresh mozz isn't even throughly cooked. I never really write reviews but that's not cool.. they didn't even have garlic knotsmade??? What kind of Pizzeria doesn't even have knots?? Definitely a big let down ???? Read more
First time being there. Alone with five kids. The staff is so nice! My husband has an exterminating company and I?ve met a lot... of restaurant employees. The way they all treated us was awesome. Their plain slice was so good. My kids were obsessed withtheir garlic knots and the salad I had was very good. I definitely recommend this place!!! Thank you staff at sals for being soaccommodating to us and kind. Read more
I have been living on Long Island my entire life and have tried many different pizza places throughout the Island. And I can... officially say that Sals of Smithtown has to take the clear number one spot! The owner and all of the employees we?re very wellmannered and the entire vibe in the pizzeria was very exciting. The pizza was phenomenal and the options that he had like thegarlic knot sliders are something I have never seen anywhere else. The menu is huge with many different options and I?mdefinitely going to come back out to Smithtown for some more good food! Read more
This 1st time experience at this place started ok. I arrived and the pizza looked pretty good (I was not greeted). I ended up... getting a Buffalo slice. I left and began eating while driving because I came on a 30min lunch break and my job was 7 min awayone way so it took me 30 min total time to get there, order and return. About 5 min and into my 4th bite I got something hardand it was a HUGE bone. I also noticed the pizza smelled like lamb and I could finish my lunch, I had to throw it out. I gave 2stars because I was unable to give the store a chance to address this due to time. In regards to the slice itself it mostly wasvery spicy so there wasn?t any flavor to enjoy. I have a pretty high spice tolerance and this slice had my entire mouth burning.The portion was bigger then most places but I couldn?t take more then 1 bite after I got that bone. A bone in your pizza issimply unacceptable. I went here for the 5 stars on google and had the worst experience ever. The short Italian looking guy whohelped me also looked mad or upset just not joy at all but he was polite and wished me well as I paid. I did feel uncomfortablewhile waiting to order just from the Ora this guy gave off. Never going back again. Read more
Very friendly place. A lot of choices. For me it needed more flavor. Is it me are places a fraid to use Basil and garlic.
Our favorite pizza place around the corner. Mi 3 yo boy love the pizza flavor.