Reviews for Sal's Pizza in Smithtown, NY
Food looked realy good, but the dough was not giving the time to rise, so it was hard and flat, we also had the garlic knot... pizza, it was not worth the extra cost, we will try it again maybe they had a flat night ,maybe staffing issues. Limited diningroom area, mainly geared towards delivery or pickup. Read more
Sals was recommended to us by a friend and the first time we tried the food we loved it. Over the next year we ordered from them... about 20 to 25 times, each time we ordered the prices went up and we said nothing because we liked the food. We always had ourfood delivered and spent around $50 to $80 with each delivery. The last order we placed the owner showed up and told us "don'torder delivery from us anymore because it's too far and we won't deliver it"! Its only a few miles away and although we live inanother town it's not that far. Regardless, who treats repeat customers like that?! We always gave a good tip and nevercomplained about the constant price changes or how long the food took to get to us. The owner is rude. Read more
Service was terrible. We were charged extra for a specialty pizza and then were told they gave 2 slices of it away to someone... else and made us choose 2 other slices instead. When we got home and opened the box it was the complete wrong pizza. Read more
I have been coming here since they opened. The variety of pizza that they make is awesome. They have the standards like buffalo... chicken and Caesar salad slices, but they also have odd ones like ravioli slices and Mac Mac slices. The pizza is excellent andso are the regular meals. They make some of the best Chicken franchise around and the portions are huge. Parking can be trickythere due to the bar at the other end of the plaza, but Sals delivers so on some days that is a better option. If you likeItalian food and have not bee here yet, check it out! Read more
The pizza was fine but as I was reading through these reviews I saw how incredibly rude and unprofessional the owner is. Someone... brought up a valid complaint about the worker not wearing a mask during a pandemic and the owner replied with "you should beashamed of yourself" and "you are no longer welcome in my place"! At no business I have worked at have we ever treated customersin such a disrespectful and immature manor! I will no longer be supporting this business. Read more
I had to take a moment to rave about how delicious Sal's Pizza is and how how amazing their staff is! I called for a last minute... delivery for my entire office and they were able to provide us all with lunch within 30 minutes! They were great on the phoneand provided recommendations for feeding the amount of staff I had on site. I strongly recommend you stop in there for a bite toeat today! Read more
Awesome pie. Eggplant we had was perfect too. Sicilian was great. Never had anything I didn?t love
Twice I went there for a slice with my daughters and both times they were closed!?! I mean it?s a Thursday night at 5:30pm and... your door is locked?? Read more