Reviews for Vintage Steak House in St James, NY
My wife and I really enjoy having a date night dinner here. The service has been excellent and the food is great. The steaks I... have had here have been cooked to perfection and flavorful. Typical ala carte steakhouse pricing, but on par with otherrestaurants in the area. Parking lot can get jammed at times but its worth going early to have a drink. The front end staff isalways pleasant and welcoming. Would highly recommend. Read more
So many steakhouses to choose from. I would give Vintage a try. Good service, as always prices are not at the low end of the... dining scale, but reasonable for a steakhouse. Read more
As I drove past a McDonalds enroute to Vintage Steak House, I thought how funny it would be to eat there on my trip to Long... Island. After reading the reviews, I was hoping for at least a memorable meal and experience at Vintage, but neither provedtrue. Service seemed almost an afterthought as those of us unfortunate enough not to get an indoor table sat for far too longbefore being able to order. It over 30 minutes between sitting down and my appetizer arriving. The scallop appetizer special wasat least warm, but the sand in my bites tells me they must not have cleaned the scallops well. But they were well cooked. Theywere chopped and placed on top of mashed potatoes that were bland. A brown sauce was underneath and it had a sour note. I wasmost pleased when I ate the scallops alone. 15 minutes later my main course of lamb chops and roasted vegetables arrived; itdidn’t last long before going back for a second attempt. The veggies were barely lukewarm upon arrival and the lamb I orderedmedium rare was almost medium well. When I told the server, he asked that I cut deeper into the chop, which didn’t improve thedoneness. The temperature on the veggies weren’t any better on the second attempt, and the meat was closer to rare. The chefforgot to season this going around, so this was a huge $86 fail. I might’ve just had a one off bad experience, but the tablenext to me sent the majority of their steak back, so maybe it was just the night. Too bad. Unless you know someone here who willtake care of you, I’d recommend a hard pass and opt instead for the Big Mac and fries. Read more
We're big Lugers fans and have said every time we've been to Vintage "Why do we need to travel west when we have this place in... our backyard?" Excellent food, excellent service and a generally great atmosphere. Vintage is quickly becoming our favoritesteakhouse. Read more
Wow! Thank you to my incredible husband for making a reservation at Vintage! We celebrated our Valentine’s Day a few days... early to beat the crowd. The food was top notch and the service was incredible. I can’t believe I waited so long before tryingthis steakhouse. Located on North Country Road, the restaurant is located in a shopping center filled with other smallbusinesses. There were some parking spots in front of the restaurant, but not an over abundance. Inside, the restaurant issmall but gorgeous. It was very clean. The tables were spaced far apart. I was able to get a reservation on Opentable, superconvenient. When I arrived, I was seated immediately. My suggestion...try to get the earliest reservation possible. Even on arandom Thursday night, the restaurant had no available tables as it got later in the evening. The service was great! Ourserver, Carlos, was very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. He went over the specials with us and answered all thequestions we had. He frequently checked on us. Water refills came around often. The timing of the food was spaced far apart. Iwas able to enjoy one course at a time without feeling rushed. My only disappointment during my meal is that soda refillsaren’t included. Each soda is $3 a pop. I ordered a few French Martinis and was very impressed. I recommend them. The foodwas spectacular!! I can’t wait to come back. I was blown away by the number of food choices. The food prices were 100% worthit! I had a great meal. All steaks are ala carte. I will be reviewing what I tried: -Complimentary Bread Basket with butter:Very fresh bread, warm, a variety of pieces and was given quite a few pieces. -French Onion Soup: WHAT I’M ABOUT TO SAY IS NOEXAGGERATION...this is the BEST French Onion Soup I’ve ever had!!! The bowl it’s served in is absolutely huge. Tons of meltycheese on top, perfectly cooked onions, delicious broth. I 100% recommend this app. 5 out of 5 stars -Thai Calamari: After Ihad my s Read more
Delicious steak dinner! Make a reservation if you want to come here, outside and indoor seating, social distancing in place.... Outdoor was a heated tent.. We arrived for our reservation and seated immediately as we requested indoor when makingreservations. Great atmosphere, fire place in dining room, waiter was super nice, food, drinks and dessert top notch, worthevery penny. French onion soup one of the best I've ever had! The sides served plentiful enough for 2 or 3 people. Stafffriendly, Definitely recommend this restaurant! Read more
I LOVE French onion soup, and a picture does not do theirs justice! It was so delicious and perfectly cooked. My Ny strip was... delicious and so juicy. We ordered dessert and I started singing to my friend being silly. The waiter heard me and came backover with a candle and stuck it in his apple cobler ( which he said was amazing). I thought that was so sweet of him to do.Overall the food and staff were amazing. The staff made us feel safe and followed covid guidelines. I'd definitely recommendVintage Read more
We had a small group dinner. Food and service were excellent. The only issue was the noise. Great steaks and other sides. Will... definitely be back! Read more