Reviews for Captain Jack's Goodtime Tavern in Sodus Point, NY
Here we are at Captain Jacks in Sodus on a beautiful day, August 7th at 6:20pm. We are greeted by a disgruntled hostess stating... they are closing the kitchen early, 6:30pm. Why why why???? I get it, it hot out, hello it August. My husband works in a steelmill. 120 degree. You can?t make money if your not open and you have live entertainment with no food but alcohol. The sun isgoing down in an hour. Interesting at best!!! Please humor me with a reply as to why???? Read more
The smells outside and in were promising. The hosts and server were friendly. The drinks came timely, and that was the end of... the good time for the most part. Almost all the food came at once - soup, wings, salad, two entrees. The only thing missing wasmy 1 year old daughter's hot dog. That came out 10 minutes later. The dill wings were supposed to be extra crispy and theydefinitely were not. The flavor and blue cheese were good. The lobster Bisque had a pound of old bay seasoning on top. Reallyruined the flavor. The breaded fish fry was crispy and very good. The seafood pasta was delicious. When I expressed mydispleasure with our waitress, she offered to drop new wings and scoop off the seasoning. That was all the resolution wereceived. I would go back for a second chance if I'm in the area, but I'm not going to rush back. Read more
Food was okay, I definitely got bagged chips rather than the "house made" ones stated on the menu. When we got our bill, the... beer prices were ridiculous. My husband had four that were absolutely 12oz vs my two that were closer to 16oz and the bill cameout to $47 for just our drinks. Not quite worth it to me... Read more
Had to wait for our table to get wiped down, was wiped well had to wipe it down myself. We order wings, very delicious. Husband... order the Wayne Co. burger he loved it. I order the fish beer batted(love that you can order how you batted) with frys andonions ring. Best onions rings I've ever had! Read more
Staff was very friendly, no wait. Food however took close to an hr from the time we ordered. My wife?s Nashville chicken... sandwich tasted good; it was a bit small and the bread kinda fell apart due to it being a bit stale. My chicken fingers wereawful. Clearly frozen processed chicken for the price of fresh. I found fibers and Veins inside them. Not edible. My daughterordered the fried clam strips and they were the best thing our family got. The server was awesome!! If they put a bit moreeffort into the food, this would be a great spot. Read more
Wonderful local treasure and Sodus Bay pillar. Indoor restaurant with fireplace, enclosed dining right on the bay, outdoor... waterfront patio seating, second floor open air deck with live music summertime and reserved-for-customer docks. Excellent food,good specials and delicious desserts. Friendly and efficient staff. Reasonable prices. Read more
This is a favorite spot for this cute seaside village. Although parking is plentiful, on the weekends it can get a little tight... in the summer months. The best thing about the place was the ambience. The wings were meh, especially since we are still inBuffalo wing territory. Our entrees were simply not memorable. Not great but not horrible. Our server was fantastic - attentiveand very pleasant. The atmosphere made it worth it all. Friendly fellow patrons, a beautiful bay view and an absolutelyfantastic band were the highlight of the pleasant evening. Sitting outdoors only added to the experience.. I was pleasantlysurprised to recognize several songs, and clearly they tried to cater to a variety of tastes. Read more
Nice Relaxing water side restaurant. Food is awesome. The battered Fish fry was delicious. Nice Bartender!