Reviews for Sarah Jane's Restaurant in Somerville, NJ
Amazing restaurant. Great filet mignon. Best French onion soup that I've ever had! Angie is the best waitress in Somerset... County! Read more
Great spot with a nostalgic "visiting with family" vibe! Food was delicious and service was fast! Definitely going back!
went there for the first time tonight the food and the service was awesome. The cream of chicken and rice soup was homemade was... really good an had moist pieces of chicken. My husband had the French onion soup an said it was the best he had in along time tasted like his mom used to make?? we both had burgers and they were absolutely delicious! 100 percent fresh ground beef. Myhusband ordered the cheesecake that the chef himself came out and told him he made fresh that day. My hubby said it was thebest cheesecake he ever had he actually called it ? beautiful ? . We will definitely go back soon to try one of the dinners. Read more
My father came up to visit from Florida and wanted to do dinner. I'm so happy my fiance recommended this place. Food was perfect... salad was a little sad but everything else was amazing. My dad keeps taking about how good the food was. Read more
Visited for the first time....Amazing atmosphere, the best Steaks, wonderful service (Angela was our waitress...very friendly... & attentive)...Loved it....Customer for life....Thank you Angela for making it a memorable evening for me & my son. Read more
Took out Tim for his 60th birthday as a treat by our dear neighbor Sheila. Made 5pm reservations for us 3, seated promptly on... arrival, greeted by our AMAZING server Olivia who was over the top on every detail. Sangria ordered, apps ordered (stuffedmushrooms and tater skins) which were great! No rush on entrees which was so relaxing. Our choices though were: Sheila(flounder/chicken Neptune {sherry cream sauce} stuffed with crabmeat), Tim got the Bleu cheeseburger with bacon, I order thespecial Prime Rib Rare cut. Everything was OUTSTANDING. Prime Rib alone was 5 stars. I asked for rare, got my rare.????. And Ican't say enough how our server Olivia, and all the staff, were so attentive and friendly. Such a good dining experience. Thankyou Sarah Jane's, and Jimmy and Jim Jr. For doing a great job. Read more
We have been driving by this place for as long as I can remember and for whatever reason we never stopped in. We finally made... reservations and checked it out; I can say it's a not so hidden gem! The food is delicious and priced how you would expect. Ihad a delicious, perfectly cooked steak and my wife had the scallops. Both portions were very generous. Inside of the restaurantlooks old but clean; the kind of place you feel comfortable at. Our waitress was great. Can't wait to go back. Read more
Best stuffed shrimp ever! Never a bad meal here. Comfortable and cozy.