Reviews for Goodfellas Pizza in South Lake Tahoe, CA
Super smalll pizza joint with a small salad bar. The pizza was really fresh and tasty. The con for me is the crust got a bit... soggy. Read more
This was probably the BEST pizza I have ever had! I'm from Philadelphia, PA. Over there, Pizza Hut is bottom of the barrel. In... Carson City, it's the best you can get. It's so refreshing to get hand made pizza for once. I paid $14 for a personal pizza, butI was not disappointed. Would highly recommend! #WhiteOut Read more
For over 20 years we never come to town without coming to Goodfella's at least once. Crust and sauce can't be beat, vibe is... great (even in the "new" location), and the food is a GREAT value. This non-Michelin reviewer gives 5 stars! Read more
The pizza was wonderful! Served fresh and hot. One one guy running the whole thing but the customers seemed satisfied.
Great pizza .Good service and prices were great as well. Pitcher beer???? .I like the decor on walls especially the lil 49er... kid. Read more
Pizza was crispy and very good. Turkey sub was really really good. Wings were ok. Bread sticks were good too. They did forget... our marinara sauce. But the taste of the food made up for it Read more
The food at Goodfellas was excellent! I ordered the lasagna, garlic bread and salad bar while the rest of my group ordered ... Calzones. I'm very glad we stumbled upon this little gem after a long day. The portions are a good size and it really hit thespot! The decor was cute and Italian/sport themed. Also, they serve Pizza by the slice, sandwiches, Pasta, Beer and wings. Don'tlet the size of this place fool you, it gets busy real fast but these guys are on it! It's Great Italian food for a reasonableprice! Read more
Good pizza, a few pasta options, limited drink selection. Really enjoyed their pesto chicken pizza. The place itself is small... with a few booths, one of which you can have all to yourself as it is facing the wall, and one that is large enough for probably6-8 adults. Sports decor blends with Goodfellas theme, and two tvs so you can watch the game without going to a sports bar. Read more