Reviews for Paisano's Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria in South Milwaukee, WI

Celebrated my birthday at Paisanos recently, the dishes were excellent that our party had ordered! The service was outstanding.... And even during these trying times with the economy at its lowest the amount of food as well as the prices were more then fair.Definitely will return again! He also recently catered a class reunion for South Milwaukee High School. The food was excellentand there was more than enough for everyone at the party. They made a number of different dishes, and there was definitelysomething for everyone who attended. Everyone commented on the quantity and great quality of the food. Thank you for making bothevents memorable. Read more

Grandson's graduation party. Lots of family! Several Large Thin Crust Sheet Pizzas. Very, Very Good! Service paid nice... attention to the 20 or so people. Giving thought to going back for takeout sometime. Read more

Had the Crab and shrimp Ravioli. Service was outrageously fast, which I suppose can be attributed to being the only people in... the restaurant. The soup was great, and the ravioli came in a surprisingly large portion and it was amazing. Some restaurantslike to be extremely petty with their portions, which leads me to steer clear of a lot of dishes. Not this restaurant. And itwas seafood nonetheless. And it also came with pudding as a dessert! A three course meal for $17? That's crazy in thistime. Will come here again. I am impressed. Read more

Best garlic bread I've ever had and what a great idea to serve pudding for dessert??????

I tried this two times because a friend had an ordered it for pickup. I do not like this pizza because the sauce is too sweet.... But I'm going into the restaurant and looking at the menu they do have pasta dishes some salmon specials and they look prettygood while waiting for the pizza they said we'll take a half an hour and it was an hour. Didn't tell us that they were behindand we had groceries in the car that had to be refrigerated on that 95° day. So all I can review on is the pizza which I do notlike at all Read more

OMG! We travel all over the world. I had an unbelievable fish and chip in Edinburgh. I had unbelievable "chicken" dish in South... Africa. I've had unforgettable experiences with food all over. THIS is another one! I always eat Italian "pre-race." Istopped here for my pre race dinner, and I'm so glad I did. I had the "Italian Connection" and my 15 year old son had thechicken fettuccine alfredo. We both declare...it was the best italian we ever had. Off the charts! Real italian! Real "downhome" restaurant! If this place were back home...it would be over twice the price! And the banana and chocolate pudding wasbanging too! It makes Olive Garden look cheap and fake. Thank you Paisano's for the experience! Read more

Five stars, all the way.... The service was superb. The ladies here were nice and accommodating. We had a birthday dinner there... for my mom and they offered to take our cake to the fridge in the kitchen until it was time to cut it. They made sure we weresatisfied with everything. They were so warm and cozy. Felt like we were over someone's house having a get together. Prices werevery reasonable even during these trying times. Our food was hot and delicious. This was not only one of the best restaurantsI've ever been to, but a great overall business. Cheers to these young ladies that took care of us! This restaurant is a musteverytime I visit MKE! Read more

From food to service this place was spot on! food was so freshly good and our lady that waited on me and my mom was so on top of... our needs and was so sweet. This was our first time here and it wont be our last, I highly suggest trying this place out andcome hungry lol Read more