Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in South Plainfield, NJ
If I could rate this place 0 stars I would. We noticed the huge chunk of mold in the sauce cups after dipping multiple times. We... are disgusted and nauseous. I called and the manager said he would only refund the cheese sticks instead of the whole order.Horrible customer service. Read more
Gotta dig thoz brownies. Ive had lots n theirs is my fav. Far as the pizza, the staff makes the texture of the dough so soft n... chewy I'm reluctant to put it in the fridge n reheat it. Read more
Not bad. The food comes out the way you order it most of the time. I haven't had any issues when ordering online and picking it... up. A solid Papa John's location. Update : Ordered my pizza with pepperoni but did not get any on my pizza. One less star forthe omission. Read more
Good tasty pizza and quick customer service!
Ordered today and got the food like 10-15 min ago. Cheesy bread was not fluffy like normal and it wasn't cut in slices all the... way through. The buffalo papadia was just white chicken with onions and no sauce or spice to it! Read more
Had an worst pizza from here today .. no crust at all .. it seems like they dumped all veggies into my pizza .. I see only... veggies than pizza here .. attached photo for reference. Read more
I ordered garlic bread and it was half cooked , waste to order, never order from this store again
The spinach topping on the pizza. Is the spinach supposed to smell like weed or is that how baked spinach smells. Idk i eat... spinach at home all the time frozen, smothie, fresh and always get spinach on pizza but as of late this pizza the spinachtopping has really strong smell. It would be crazy to think employees are contaminating orders idk. that would be illegal?? Read more