Reviews for Pontillo's Pizzeria in Spencerport, NY

Bought a chicken wing pizza and medium buffalo wings well done. The chicken wing pizza was just awful, which is upsetting,... having grown up in spencerport and it use to be the best in this area. There was so much parsley that it was unbearable, barelyany buffalo sauce and barely any chicken. Basically just a cheese pizza with parsley on every square inch. The wings, I?ll saywere cooked well done like I requested but had next to no sauce on them, to the point I added my own sauce because I didn?t askfor plain. We?ve tried giving this place so many chances and every time it disappoints. The owner is a great person, always veryfriendly but his staff could care less. Do not recommend. Read more

They suck, wings not cooked well. Should crispy all over. Pizza didn't have hardly any sauce. Super skimpy toppings. Hardly any... cheese. Soggy in the middle. I won't order from tem again. We have so many other great pizza places here in town. Why would goback to them. Terrible! Read more

Had a sheet and 24 wings delivered last night to a party I was having. Up on delivery this is what the pizza looked like

2.5 stars. Very good when the owner makes the food. When He isnt there, you're going to get one of the worst pizzas. Ordered... last night and got an undercooked pizza with burnt toppings and rotten, actually rotten mushrooms on top. I know the ownerwould've been appalled to send that pizza out. I had to throw it away. Shame. Read more

Always love the food...but to be honest, simple pizza and wings are getting a bit expensive. A medium 2 topping pizza, and 12... wings over $35?? We'd eat it more often, but simply can't afford to... Read more

The wings here were so fabulous! We tried the barbecue, garlic and country sweet. They were crispy on the outside and moist... inside. The pizza was good too but for us the show stoppers were the wings. Read more

No Excuse for this they ruined a totally decent family night with myself ,my wife and daughter . we were Bowling at our favorite... bowling alley and thought why not order a Pizza from Pontillo's since they are right across the Street, we placed the order ittook them over an hour to deliver which I could not understand ,then I bite into the first piece and found a 6 to 8 inch pieceof hair in my pizza. yeah I complained yeah I got a refund but the mood and dinner was ruined this is the Last time we orderfrom there there is no reason what so ever employees don't have hair tied up Tied up or covered Read more

Their pizza was really good with the heat from the pepperoni. I also order chicken wings which were good sized, but I didn't... like the wings not being extra well done like I asked for. They did add extra sauce for the wings which I liked. Read more