Reviews for Amato's in St Johnsbury, VT

Manager was very rude . Yelling in the background at the women who was taking our order that we need to call an hr ahead. We... called in at 11am picked up 12pm . He was yelling so loud we had to give her our order again. Then when order was picked up hecame zooming in and wanted to know where we got a menu. We will not order there again. We always are curtious and leave a tip.The woman that took our order apologized that she couldn't hear. She was very nice on the phone and at pickup. Day before when Ipicked up he also was talking very loudly to the help demanding why there was a backup. They were doing the best they could . Itwas very busy. Read more

Amatos gets one star because the manager was rude and abusive to his employee and customers. I was so embarrassed for the... female employee that was working so hard to take our order while this manager yelled at her repeatedly. We order out a fewtimes a week and love to support our local businesses, but Amatos will not be getting our business so long as that abusive manis allowed to be in charge of employees and allowed to treat customers with such distaste. Read more

The food was delicious but the Manger is rude and doesn't seem to want to take orders over the phone. Couldn't get us a menu... said there was not going to be any menus. We order out at least twice a week I can assure you we will not be ordering there aslong as that manager is still there. Customer service is very important. We're very polite always give a tip and want tosupport our local businesses. Read more

Decent food for a convenience store. I wanted some pasta when I parked my truck. Better than Pizza Hut pasta, that is for... sure. One thing that I find strange is that the signs outside the store advertise pasta, but it is nowhere to be found on thein-store menu. However pasta is an option on the kiosk, so I orderer some ziti with meatballs and sausage on the kiosk. Read more

Order a sandwich with mayo and mustard with no salt and pepper just had ham, cheddar cheese, lettuce, spinach on it they... made it completely wrong with oil on it and slat and pepper no mayo or mustard it was gross Read more

Gone there twice for sandwiches. Both experiences awful. First time the guy was touching papers and cans etc while he was... waiting for my sandwich to grill. No gloves. Second time I ordered a Turkey sandwich, they gave me ham. Therr was hair in itand the tape they used also had a wad of hair stuck to it. Read more

I got a full order of 12 stuffers. I figured I would eat some now and save some for later. I couldn't stop...SO. MUCH. CHEESE!

A bit pricey for gas station food. However, what I requested was grilled to order. I would go back more often if the prices... were a bit lower. Thanks- Read more