Reviews for The Cove New York Style Pizzeria in State College, PA

It might not be fair that I gave a non-descript two star review just because the guy saw me coming and turned the open sign off... early. I honestly wouldn’t have gone in if I saw they were 5-10 minutes away from closing because I feel bad doing that to theemployees, but I just felt resentful because I was tired and hungry. I wish google maps would let you choose NA for the Staramount and just comment. I wish I could say whether or not I like the food! I’ll change it to a 3 since I don’t have a broadperspective of the restaurant. Read more

Nice cozy little pizza shop! Will def go back my 8 year old ate a whole small pizza and loved the chocolate cake!

Any pizza we get is great! Love the crust, sauce, cheese, and toppings! Everything we've ordered there has been good. Fast... delivery every time. Read more

Ordered from here twice, felt nickel-and-dimed both times. Order 1: got a cheese pizza, jalapeno poppers, and onion ring. Pizza... was decent. Poppers were tasty but tiny, not much for 9 bucks. Onion rings were 7.50 and we got 7 rings total, three of whichwere very small; over a dollar a ring? They're onion rings. You can make 4-5 orders out of one onion. Order 2: got a 10" deluxepizza and chicken parm dinner. Pizza was 9" at most, and parm dinner for 14 bucks was very small. Also, sauce on parm dinner wasnearly tasteless, and the fried chicken tasted like it was overfried in old oil (acrid, burnt taste). Overall, just okay food(thus the 2 stars), but waaaay overpriced for what you get. Read more

Just had a wonderful lunch. The bread was fresh baked, the food delicious, and the service great! House-made dessert to take... home was a must:) Will be back! Read more

I love the atmosphere, nice quiet little place. Friendly employees there, the food and the sauce on the pizza and subs was... delicious. The only reason I gave it four stars was the cheese was very thick and it didn't look completely melted. It wouldhave been nice if the cheese was more "well done" . The pizza also no color on the bottom of it and drooped like a noodle.With the exception of those two things,everything tasted really good and I would go back. Read more

Top 3 best pizza at state. Very thin slices though. So you can eat a ton.

Good quality food. Got a Philly cheesesteak, loaded cheese fries and cannoli. I am not happy with the fact that I selected extra... meat and cheese on my cheesesteak, and yet it's skimpy in volume. Save your $3.25 and don't order extra toppings. The half notpictured was even less filled. Still tastes good which is nice. Read more