Reviews for Pier 76 in Staten Island, NY
Can?t recommend this restaurant enough! The thin crust pizza is among the best I?ve ever tasted. (And, trust me, I?ve tasted... more than my share). This morning I am still talking about the mussels in the most intensely flavored sauce ever! Thebartender/waiter who greeted us was warm and very friendly. Shout out to his Bloody Mary! This isn?t just a ferry stoprestaurant. We live an hour away in New Jersey and we can?t wait to return. And, of course kudos to the kitchen! Read more
We visited this place after seeing it on youtube. We were not disappointed. Danny the server was extremely welcoming and helpful... when recommending both the beer and the food. We ordered a large pizza half vodka sauce and half buffalo chicken. Both toppingwere incredible on top of a perfect thin base. Would highly recommend. Read more
The perfect rating is a must simply because of the marriage between price point and quality. The regular cheese pie at Pier 76... is top notch taste and Monday through Thursday there?s a $10 pie special ($10.99 with tax). The thin crust, the cheese, and thesauce all high-grade. It?s an unbelievable deal, the $10 special, and that?s what I always get and that?s why I?m giving 5stars. There?s two other pizza places on Staten Island that really impressed me: one, Paulie?s on Bay St, is out of business.The other one, the well known Joe & Pat?s, is very good but rates slightly lower than P76. P76 has better location too, rightacross from ferry. And J&P weekday special is $2 more. And last but not least?the sauce?sauce, I feel, gets overlooked when itcomes to pizza, but that?s what really separates ok pizza from great pizza. P76 pie has good sauce! I?ve also tried the calamarionce and I would get it again; I enjoyed it, however, the calamari costs more than a pie and I pretty much plan to keep spending$10.99 for a great pizza as long as I can! Read more
We found out about this place from someone that grew up on Staten Island. We stop by every chance we can. The Italian is... AMAZING. the pizza is some of the best I've had and their pasta is top notch. We were most recently there after the 5 borobike tour and with 32k riders ending at their doorstep, they were swamped. Even with the crowds, they delivered great for in afun place. Can't wait for the next time I'm nearby! Read more
PROS: This place was very quant. Small place with a full bar, nice seating area, and a pizza parlor connected to it. Their pizza... was amazing and the staff was very nice. Seems to be a place locals go to. Menu has large variety at good prices CONS: Hardlyparking and the place can fill up quickly due to it's size. OVERALL: I highly recommend coming here if you're in the area, Iknow i'll be coming back here soon! Read more
A hole in the wall pizza place - it has a dine-in and take out parts of the restaurant. Our server was good, she was busy with... bar duties and serving so keep that in mind if you expect to have a typical dining service. ( I personally was a fan of thisservice!) The food is fantastic! We got a Margarita and a heart shaped pizza - both were yum! Read more
I love the pizza I love the service the people are sweet and kind. And the food is always great. I travel from the other side of... Staten Island just for their Pizza. Chicken tender and the cheese garlic bread is delicious ????. The staff are very pleasant .My wife and I go here alot. You will not be disappointed. Read more
Location is near the street, and it's easy to grap a drink and hang out. Atmosphere and service are very nice. However the Pizza... at this place is fairly average compared to the price and the qualities other pizzeria can offered on Staten Island, let alonethe Brooklyn's. Any pizza comes with the meat are pricey and over-rated. Chicken sicilian slice is a big disappointment.Recommend to only get the plain Sicilian slice, if you come here for pizza. Read more