Reviews for Turtle Cove Resort & Marina in Sterling, NY
Not much to look at on the outside, inside it's nice and clean. Our server Caren was wonderful, it took a while for the food to... come out but it was worth the wait. They had live music and it wasn't too load. Read more
Seated quickly, order taken quickly by friendly waitress. Food was good, but I wouldn't say great. Very good band on the back... deck. Excellent pie for desert. Read more
We rented a cabin for two nights. Cabin was vintage but was very clean and seems well maintained. We also had dinner one night... in the restaurant as we watched a great show put on by a "local to the area" professional musician piano player and vocalistJustJoe, who was absolutely fabulous. Our dinners were very good, and the homemade peanut butter cheesecake for dessert was outof this world. Our server was attentive all night without being overbearing. Brian and his wife, (sorry I didn't get her name)was very welcoming. Definitely enjoyed everything about the Turtle Cove & Marina. Read more
The dining room was fairly empty but extremely loud with guests next to us. Our food was absolutely awful. I had an impossible... burger that was made on the same surface as the rest of the meat. Nothing was seasoned. My husband got a steak special. (Rare).1/3 of it was just fat. Another 1/3 was well done. The last 1/3 was rare. Our waitress had the personality of a rock. We willnot return. Read more
We went to Turtle Cove for dinner while on vacation in Fair Haven. We completely enjoyed the dining on the dock. The food was... great, the service was awesome especially for a Monday evening. Can't wait to return! Read more
Love turtle cove. The food and drinks are amazing. The view is beautiful. We always have a good time everytime we are here. A... bigger parking lot is definitely a must. We always go on a Thursday-saturday when it's pretty busy but no complaints. Theservice is very good. Read more
Enjoyed a tasty lunch and local IPAs (Rochester) on a perfect day on Fair Haven Bay. Plenty of outdoor seating with tables not... too crowded. Steak & Blue Cheese Flatbread was absolutely delicious, wait staff friendly and very attentive. Family of Swanscircling the area were a pleasure to watch. A nice find. Read more
Being from out the area and this place happened to be open, we stopped for a bite to eat after visiting the park. Friendly staff... and locals. Food was great. Flatbread was great! Will return when back in the area Read more