Reviews for Polito's Pizza in Stevens Point, WI
Mmmm! Always such fine pizza!! And even a pinball! Just know they close the restaurant inside around 8pm.
Best pizza in Steven's Point and arguably the best in the Mid State. The Extra Large veggie pizza is my usual go to as the... slices are HUGE and at 24 dollars, a really great deal. I love going to this location with my wife and play pinball as theyconsistently update the machine here. Amazing selection of beverages from beer to bottle sodas. Read more
Oh my gosh.... The itallian Beef sub was 10 out 10. The au jus is homemade and thick! Incredible, I can't say much more. ... The peppers, the cheese, the bread, the flavor all intertwined...wow. Read more
We use Polito?s to cater probably every-other party we have! Pizza is DE-lish! ????????????
Best pizza I?ve had in a very long time. Slices are huge. Ordered the XL and that filled me and my two 17yr olds right up. Best... price I?ve seen on a pizza this size too. The Resturant itself is very clean, fun atmosphere. They also sell pizza by the slice.Staff was very friendly and that is hard to find anymore. Polito?s management Thank You for a great restaurant with the beststaff around. Next time I?m in Stevens Point, I?ll be back. Read more
Out of all of the college town pizzerias, I will definitely put this place on my top list of pizza joints. A lively crowd comes... in late after two from the club. However if you don?t mind the fun and excitement of seeing that, this is the place foryou. Much ???? KD Read more
We have had many a pizza from here. We usually get the large cheese to go, take it home and add topping and cook it for another... 10 minutes. I have never really liked the crust, seemed too soft and I suspected they came pre-made. The last time I visited mywife and I got a couple slices, dine in. I watched them throw the dough, not pre-made! The crust on the pizza was excellent,nice crunch on the outside but a good tooth on the inside. Crunchy and chewy like a good New York style crust should be. Ithough they must have changed the recipe or something and asked about it. They were baffled at first but then one guy said, "our slice oven is broken so we heated it up in the pizza oven which is much hotter." Duh! The crust has been fine these lastthree years, it just has not been cooked hot or long enough. When you order a slice ask them to heat it up in the pizza oven,waaayyy better. I'm mostly a purist when it comes to pizza but they are known for all kinds of toppings on their pizzas so ifthat's your thing you should be happy. Tried the macaroni and cheese pizza, it was okay, the cheese was very mild, maybe use acouple stronger cheeses? The staff are always nice. Place is a little grungy but not dirty, if you know what I mean. Read more
Amazing Pizza! Huge portion for a great price. Fast, friendly service.