Reviews for Original Italian Pizza in Stewartstown, PA

James 1 year ago

This place is a joke. My wife had her kidney removed today we get home from the hospital I order originals and specifically say... I want my sub plain. It gets delivered incorrect and due to allergies I cannot eat it. We have a newborn so I can?t leave thehouse so I try to call originals to see if they can bring me my correct order THEY LITERALLY WOULDNT PICK UP FOR 15 MIN BEFORECLOSE AND I NEVER GOT ANYONE BACK ON THE PHONE. I WILL NEVER EVER EVEN IF THE WORLD IS COMING TO END ASK THEM FOR A MEAL AGAIN. Read more

Rick Michaud 1 year ago

Only have been here a few times. Every time the food was great, staff is always friendly and pieces are reasonable. Would... recommended if you haven't eaten here before. Read more

kenzie Abbott 1 year ago

so the food here is really good lol but the other day i literally saw the owner chase a customer out of the restaurant. a few... people had to chase after him. i?ve heard by asking around that it was simply because their menus are outdated, and the customerdidn?t know that a sandwich was as much as it was, and didn?t have enough money to pay for it so when he tried to leave theowner literally chased him down. not the craziest thing i?ve seen walking down the street but still pretty crazy. Read more

Annie May 1 year ago

We were just sitting enjoying our drinks when we accidentally poked our flimsy cups and it spilled everywhere. They came over to... clean it up and seemed angry. Then 4 more people came in so they made our whole table move to a different table???? The servicewas bad however the pizza was very good. Read more

Ash Starr 1 year ago

Steadily going downhill since we moved to the area in 2020. If you want a cheese steak go to Messina's. Their Greek boli was a... fave but that's lacking now too. Pizza is meh because it's hit or miss if it's any good. I feel like if the owner makes it, it'sgood but when it's the other guy they have it's just lacking. Read more

Susan 1 year ago

Much like OIP's I grew up with, this place has great food. My 2 year old even ate all 3 of his chicken fingers! (Yes, that's... mind-blowing to me.) Husband and I split a cheese steak and it was quite tasty and pretty filling. Will definitely go backagain. Read more

Mike Hill 2 years ago

I always enjoyed food from this place growing up nearby. Unfortunately, I ordered online for Mother's Day this year and the... delivery never came. Nearly $100 worth of food and gave the max tip allowed by their online ordering system (Menufy). I requestrefund/help through Menufy and days later Menufy emailed me back saying the restaurant will not refund. A real shame but Iwon't be ordering from here again. Read more

Brandy LeBlanc 3 years ago

I?ve always been a big OIP fan - food is consistently high quality, large portions, and the person taking orders & serving food... is always happy to serve. Today I ordered my first delivery & the driver was so kind! He delivered quickly & started genuineconversation. He represented OIP well! (Blonde teen - give him props!) Thanks for another great meal! Read more