Reviews for Borghi's By The Bay in Stone Harbor, NJ

We were extremely disappointed with our experience. At this time of year one would expect to get more vegetables in the side8... salad. The salmon was not described as spicy but it was. The stuffed flounder was definitely overpriced and one of our group wasserved hers cold. We were disappointed with the the menu choices because we had looked at the online menu and most of theofferings were not on our menu tonight. I would suggest that you tell your patrons the cost of the specials before they order.Considering your other prices, $56 for the flounder was definitely out of line. On the positive side our server was amiable. Read more

Best meal ever!!! Ordered lobster Fra Diavolo (one of the specials) and it?s Amazing!! Seasoned perfectly. We were seated... immediately. Dino & Terry always make us feel like family. Warm bread and pesto dipping sauce is always a great start to ourdinner. Hand made mozzarella sticks are a die for appetizer special. Can?t go wrong with BYOB. Favorite and goto place. Placeis getting more and more popular recommend making reservations. Read more

Perfect location for a private Birthday celebration. The food was fantastic from the appetizers to the main course, to the... dessert and coffee ?. Our entire party of 7 was very happy with this restaurant and the quality of food they served. We werecelebrating my nieces's birthday at the beach and we couldn't be more happy with our choice. The location, the food, and theservice was top notch. Do not miss this hidden gem in Stone Harbor. Read more

We had a lovely meal here last week. Large family consisting of meat eaters, sea food eaters, kids, babies, and even three... vegetarians and everyone enjoyed their food. The bread came out warm! The service was good, especially considering it was acollege-aged girl. My sister felt the helping of the tuna special was a bit small, that would have been our only suggestion. Read more

Great hidden gem in Avalon! We ate on the outside deck as we watched the sunset over the bay. The food was fresh and authentic.... Dino, the chef was definitely passionate about his mother's recipes! Must haves include the meatball appetizer which the 4 of usshared and the mama's pound cake with ice cream for dessert. We all loved our amply sized entrees (see pics) including porkchop, veggie penne, chicken parm and the fra diavlo seafood special over thin spaghetti. Will be back! Read more

I ordered take out from here. My omelette was great, however I felt they really rationed the home fries (which are my favorite... part of breakfast). It is not worth the price for the meals. It also came with soggy bread, not toasted. Personally, I wouldn?trecommend nor return to Borghi?s. Read more

This place is no joke, the best dinner on the Jersey shore. My wife had Chilean sea bass, shrimp, artichokes and spinach, all... seared and served in a tasty white sauce. I had a grilled seafood platter with salmon, shrimp, scallops, asparagus on a bed ofarugula. It was incredible. We're considering going again tomorrow. We started with warm homemade bread freshly baked, and pestothat was just out of this world. And finished with pound cake, ice cream and chocolate sauce, and whipped cream that was largeenough for us to split. It was all 5 star served in a comfortable porch seating. Service was good, food came comfortably quick.I would highly recommend this place. Read more

Everything was delicious! The owner/chef made our meal memorable. The mozzarella sticks were huge. My 5 year old daughter ate... them all. We shared meatballs and I had the Salmon. This place is BYOB. There is outside seating with a gas fire pit. We will beback for sure. Read more