Reviews for Don's Pomeroy House in Strongsville, OH
In our continuing efforts to try local restaurants in and around the Berea area, our realtor gifted us a gift card to Don't... Pomery house. Celebrating our wedding anniversary, we decided tonight would be an excellent night to try it out. We had made areservation in advance earlier in the week, which was not necessary for the time we arrived (around 5:45p) We were seatedimmediately at a two top table along the outer wall. There were just a handful of tables with other patrons at thetime. Ambiance was very overall very nice with the atmosphere being cozy and close quarters. Overall volume level was low astables were generally using inside voices to talk and not out at a concert near the speakers that some restaurants breed by allthe TV's and noise. Food wise, everything was wonderful as one would hope. We ordered the calamari for an appetizer, which wasexcellent. Cooked to perfection and topped with a sweet chili pepper sauce, it was fantastic. I ordered the soup of the day,chicken and dumplings, which had excellent flavor but lacked some substance and was generally broth overall. Ordered the Pomeryhouse salad and was very pleased by the blend of the mandarin oranges, greens, and strawberries. The honey poppyseed dressingwas extremely sweet so a little bit of it went a very long way. For the main dish, I ordered the 8 oz filet mignon. It wasserved with gold Yukon mashed potatoes, mushrooms, a brown gravy, and French beans. Steak was cooked exactly as requested(medium) and was buttery in texture and consistency. The mashed potatoes blended well with the gravy adding a great flavorenhance to the whole dish. For dessert, we were offered a free eclair in celebration of our anniversary and we also ordered thebread pudding to try. The eclair was very tasty with a very rich chocolate frosting and an excellent custard center. Some of thebest custard filling I have had outside of a bakery. I was told the bread pudding was excellent with it's blend of fruit Read more
The food and drinks at the restaurant was flavorful and amazing. The service here is spectacular. The staff is very attentive... and they all have great energy. My husband and I love a great dining experience and this exceeded our expectations. I got thechicken and mashed potatoes. That seems pretty unoriginal but their presentation and the flavors were great. One thing most finedinner places miss is the seasoning. This place is an exception. I don't know who is is that kitchen but they are seasoning foodwell. Read more
I’m not gonna lie, this is probably one of the best dinners I’ve had in a long time. Went here for an anniversary with my bf... and this place was awesome. From the food to the atmosphere to our awesome waitress (I’m honestly so sad that I can’tremember her name) this place was amazing. We couldn’t recommend this place enough and will definitely come back for morespecial events! Read more
This is one of the best restaurants in Strongsville. I love their grilled romaine. I'll order it every time I go there. Highly... recommend this place for a date night or a great lunch! I love that they've stepped up their bread game. Bread says a lot abouta restaurant. Read more
Have come here for years for birthdays, anniversaries & whenever. Today was an extreme disappointment. The grouper was small &... not worth $40. A few potatoes & asparagus, service was outstanding. Ate at the bar & Janie was outstanding, the bang bangshrimp & shrimp cocktail were worth the price. Also had the green fried tomatoe not bad. Won’t be back til the winter to givethem another chance, but if the fish stays small in portion, then they have lost a customer Read more
Great dinner tonight. The grilled romaine salad was fantastic. Braised short rib and the scallops dinners were delicious. A... Strongsville icon! Read more
Wonderful experience! Even though it was packed, they were able to seat us in the unique speak easy like atmosphere downstairs... where our bartender and waitress Gayle was on point. I couldn't have asked for a better evening! Thank you for always beingconsistently excellent in making the entrees delectable... Read more
Meals are always prepared exquisitely as is the Don's tradition. Brought a friend from Chicago for dinner in the pub. He was... astonished by the menu, prices, and his meal - the black and blue strip. He commented on every bite. Read more