Reviews for Nightingale Supper Club in Sturgeon Bay, WI
Absolutely delicious! I had the Ribeye with Shrimp and baked potato. My fiancé had the surf & turf! It was outstanding. Our... server, Josie, was fantastic and pleasant. We will make this a stop when traveling up her. Read more
Great place!! The prime rib was the best I?ve had in years. Great mashed potatoes, great drinks, great service and atmosphere.
Sad that I?m not able to experience such tasty food more often, lol.. If I lived in the area this would probably be my go-to. We... had a 6pm reservation and we were sat promptly. Within 15 minutes of sitting we?d already had our drinks and our appetizer (thestuffed mushrooms ????), I got a salad with my entree and would?ve preferred some more cucumbers and tomatoes but really wishedI would?ve gotten the lobster soup that my boyfriend got because it was SO tasty dipped with the warm bread. From the appetizerto dessert I was seriously impressed! Next time I?m in Door County I plan on stopping in again. Read more
Very nice dining experience. The server (Jana) was excellent, as was the bartender. The food was delicious (Salmon,... Hollandaise sc. and asparagus for me, and breaded shrimp for my husband) The atmosphere was very nice. We will return. Read more
Our nephew was here from Denver, Colorado and he requested that we go to The Nightengale. We were seated right away, old... fashion drinks fabulous and the perch and baked cod dinners delicious! Excellent service and food! Read more
Firstly I would like to say the customer service was over the top, From the bar to the table every employee made sure we had... our drinks , made sure our food was exactly what we ordered ( delicious may i Add ), absolutely the best experience yet thisyear at an establishment, we will definitely be back again soon , we definitely recommend you try the mushrooms they are out ofthis world at first you taste the cream and at the backside the bacon not to mention the prime rib has been the best yet in DoorCounty !!! Hands down best dinner experience yet!!! Thank you , John , Ferra Hailee and Jessica for the amazing experiencetonight at your establishment we will definitely be back very satisfied God bless!!!! Read more
Slight wait even with reservations. Bar atmosphere was nice though and helped pass the time. Stuffed mushrooms were AMAZING!... Definitely would order again. Prime rib had great flavor and was cooked perfectly. My husband ordered the chicken sandwich andwas blown away by how good it was. Grasshopper to end the night was great as well. Will definitely be back! Read more
Great drinks and service. The food was good, although I would have preferred to see a greater variety of steaks on the menu (and... a relish tray is always nice at a supper club (: ). But overall, I enjoyed the place and the atmosphere and would definitely goback. Read more