Reviews for Park Street Pizza in Sugarcreek, OH
They nail it. We drove 45 minutes to check this place out and it is well worth it. The pizza has a deep dish vibe with the sauce... and cheese slightly burnt around the crust. The sauce has a freshness to it and the dough is somehow very light and fluffy.Every flavor is is the right mix of present but not too much. The bone in wings are easily some of the best Ive ever had. Theywere perfectly crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside. The building is naturally lit and has nice facilities that madechanging our baby easy, and they even had a sink outside of the bathrooms to wash your hands without having to go in. That kindof extra consideration is seen everywhere in this restaurant. My wife and I spent $60 including tip but we were taste testingspecialty pizzas and wanted to take home a bunch of leftovers. Five stars, don't pass it up. Read more
One of the best pizzas around the area. Add the hot honey to really set it off. Will make the drive here again
The absolute best pizza we have ever had! People working there are very nice. Top notch high quality pizza!
Fun little local pizza spot. Pricier, but better-quality pizza. We tried the Old World Pep/Mushroom as well as the Park Street.... My wife was happy with that Old World, and though I enjoyed the Park Street, the large-cut ingredients had a tendency to falloff. All was delicious. We also had the mozz cheesesticks, which had a good flavor but lacked melt and seemed more like frozensticks that weren?t fully heated. Still, the marinara was great with it. Very friendly staff. Read more
Wow! This restaurant is doing everything right. Excellent customer service...the young man who took our order could see my... mother struggling to understand the menu and he offered a hand held menu. He also answered questions politely and thoroughly.Pizza came out in a timely fashion and was delicious. The restaurant was clean and well-attended to by staff as customers cameand went. The drink station wasn't a sloppy mess like you see at other places but very tidy and organized. It is also a fun,well-lit, nicely decorated family atmosphere. Everything is perfect as is. If I ever visit the area again, I'll be back withmore hungry people. Read more
I feel like the pics will say more than I can express with words food wise. The staff is amazing. They really makes you feel at... home and comfortable. If you are in the heart of Amish country this is a place you should check out. Read more
We had a wonderful experience at Park Street Pizza, from the friendly employee that answered the phone to the delicious pizza!... We placed our order on Thanksgiving weekend and had to try several times due to the phone being busy! We knew it was a busyevening, so it was no surprise when the wait was just over an hour! It was well worth the wait! The pizza was perfectly made anddelicious! Highly recommend! Read more
A staple to my hometown, Park Street Pizza is where you take your friends when you want to impress with high-quality pizzas that... you won?t find anywhere else. Over our many visits and pick-ups, Park Street has continued to provide excellent service, qualityingredients, and fair pricing. My current favorite is the Modern Margherita - though any of their pizzas, from a classicpepperoni to a specialty pizza, will not leave you wanting for more. Read more