Reviews for Tracey's Seafood in Sullivan, ME
Decent place. I wish the menu were a little more diverse, but also totally understand the hardships around. One thing that'd be... helpful too is if the side pie that can be chosen as a side didn't come til after the main meal was served. By the time Ifinished, my pie was sitting in liquid whipped cream and blueberry water. Probably a little lobster liquid too because lobsteris quite a messy meal. Overall, it was ok. Read more
Food was good people were friendly. We ordered the captain s platter for 2. Decent price...more than we could eat. Brought... enough home for 1 more meal! Read more
We have stopped by Tracey's a couple of times this past summer (2022) for their lobster rolls. The roll looks small when you... first get it, but it is fully packed with what seems like half a lobster. Well worth the price for a fresh, tasty lobster roll.The place doesn't look like much - it's more or less a "hole in the wall" sort of place - but it is a popular spot with thelocal folks, which means the value and quality is very acceptable. There is a small dining room, but most folks opt to stand inline at the takeout window and eat at one of several picnic tables on the premises. Read more
Pros: We had lobster rolls two days in a row. Two for $20 so good value and overall tasty and good portions. Server was pleasant... and friendly staff. Fries were typical frozen type, nothing special. Cons: The Cook on day 2 was wearing a sleeveless open pitt-shirt and no beard net. Had a b-ball cap. Really BAD optics for food sanitation and if we saw that before our order, probablywould have moved on. Makes on question how management oversees restaurant cleanliness. Read more
First - The food was great. The lobster rolls had more meat than any other place I have had the last few days and wasn?t bread... heavy. My wife got chicken tenders and they weren?t fried with the seafood, so they didn?t have a ?fishy taste? like otherplaces sometimes do. Tried some clams and haddock too and both were fried to the perfect consistency. I didn?t get a photo whenthe food came, but after I already crushed the onion rings and the other sandwich. Last - It was a long wait because they areunderstaffed. They told us an hour, but it was 1hr45min for take out from the window. They were apologetic for the delay and wejust hung out and made friends with others waiting. We were there late at closing time and the place was packed while wewaited. Overall - It?s a great place with great food that is some of the cheapest around. Just call ahead for wait times. Read more
A friendly and tasty stop Down East. The fried food is crispy and not greasy. My clams and onion rings were delicious and my... husband?s Jumbo Haddock burger WAS a jumbo piece of fish. The staff were very friendly even on a busy, hectic day. Read more
Best lobster roll I?ve ever had! For a great price too! Ice cream was also super good, I had a banana split and it was... definitely one of the better ones I?ve had. Easy to get to since it?s just off the road. Service was great. The staff wasfriendly. Only complaint I had was that it took a while to get my food, but besides that I would definitely go here again. Read more
We stopped for takeout one evening right around 5:00pm. It was September so things were slowing down. There are no prices on the... menu displayed outside but they have paper menus with prices if you ask for one. We ordered the two for $20 lobsters rolls, andthe seafood chowder. It took about 15 minutes to get our food. The lobster rolls were not overly stuffed but they had a decentamount of chunky lobster with a light mayonnaise dressing. They were served on a buttered, toasted roll. There were some randomshells we found while eating. In the end, the rolls were satisfying enough. The seafood chowder cost $15. It was mostly whitefish (I presume haddock) and these tiny, tiny, tiny shrimp. There was a ½ piece of scallop. There were no clams ? which is oddto me. Also, no vegetables ? which is ok ? just seafood. The broth was a light cream sauce so it was not thick. The chowder wasoverly salty to me but I added some sherry at home which lightened it up. Tracey?s has lots of different types of fried seafood.And lots of ice cream, hard and soft. There are outdoor picnic tables and a small room inside with maybe 10 tables. They willserve you indoors but not out. The restaurant is right on route 1 so it?s pretty noisy. Read more